Paying Employees with Paycards? The Pros and Cons
woman-looking-at-payroll-paycard

Paying Employees with Paycards? The Pros and Cons

With the rise and ease of direct deposit, paper paychecks have pretty much gone the way of the dinosaurs. But, did you know there’s another paperless option you can use to pay your employees? Paycards offer a distinct advantage to employees who are underbanked – those who have a bank account but rely largely on unconventional finance options such as check cashing services – or unbanked – those who don’t have a banking relationship at all. Their wages are simply loaded to a reusable, refillable card that can then be used at points of purchase or ATMs.

Estimates from a 2017 Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) survey showed that 6.5% of households in the United States were unbanked, representing approximately 8.4 million households. Additionally, 18.7%, or 24.2 million, were underbanked. More than 30% of these households have an annual family income of $25,000 or less. And, while unbanked and underbanked employees can be found in all industry segments, the greatest concentration can be found in construction, staffing, hotels, and franchise businesses such as restaurants.

Pros of Paycards for Employees and Employers

Providing payments directly through a debit card saves you money by not wasting it on the paper used to print checks. Payroll debit cards for employees also eliminates the manual preparation, printing and distributing required from your payroll department, letting them focus on other tasks and saving your company money. Additionally, using a paycard can save your unbanked employees time and eliminate the exorbitant fees charged by expensive check-cashing stores and predatory payday lenders. And, they get the same legal protections from fraud that debit card holders have.

paying-with-paycard

Paycard Challenges

As with any form of pay, paycards do have some considerations to look out for. Depending on the provider you use, the cards can hit employees with fees for items such as monthly maintenance, point-of-sale charges, ATM use, and some even charge for calling to check the card balance. It wouldn’t take many $1.50 ATM fees to wipe out an hour’s worth of work for employees who make minimum wage.

Another consideration: although employee paycards can be a money-saver for your company, you legally can’t require employees to switch to that payment method. You have to provide the option of a paper paycheck or direct deposit.

Best Practices for Payroll Card Use

If your company decides to use paycards, it’s best to follow a few simple rules to help ensure you stay in compliance with state and federal laws:

  • Do not make the paycards mandatory; ensure you have other pay options.
  • Select a paycard company that has limited fees.
  • Ensure that you disclose all details about the paycard versus other pay options.
  • Ensure that the paycard company you select allows employees to withdraw the full amount of their pay each pay period in multiple withdrawals without fees.
  • Ensure there is a sufficient number of ATMs and stores nearby where the card can be used for purchases or cash withdrawals.


Subscribe to Our Resource Center Digest

Enter your email below to receive a weekly recap of the latest articles from Paycor's Resource Center.

Check your inbox for an email confirming your subscription. Enjoy!

More to Discover

HR Statistics You Need to Know for 2020

HR Statistics You Need to Know for 2020

The world of human resources is constantly evolving. With the introduction of “gig” jobs like Uber and high-tech advancements, employees have more power than ever. There's a new desire to find a balance between work and life.There are more job openings than candidates. And opportunities to change jobs are abundant. Workers have less reason to rely on and remain loyal to their employers. Especially if their employers don’t offer employees what they want.With 2020 right around the corner, we’re looking at the stats and trends we’ve seen in human resources, hiring, and workplace culture. The future is here. So, it’s important to understand the current climate and be ready. General HR Trends and Statistics Candidates moving through the...

The Turnover Crisis in Retail: An Action Plan for Owners and Operators

The Turnover Crisis in Retail: An Action Plan for Owners and Operators

When examining turnover rates by industry, retail rises to the top. In 2018, the average retail turnover rate eclipsed 60%, with employees citing better opportunities, promotions, pay raises and a desire for more hours as top reasons for leaving. Retailers have constantly battled turnover for years, but it’s become especially problematic during the holiday season when employers enter into an arms race to fill jobs. The Negative Effects of Turnover Human Resources Today found that retail turnover translates into more than 230 million days of lost productivity and $19 billion for recruiting, hiring and training expenses. And when consumers visit a brick and mortar store, many are looking for a true shopping experience. But when employees...

3 Reasons to Invest in a Learning Culture: Recruit, Retain, Engage

3 Reasons to Invest in a Learning Culture: Recruit, Retain, Engage

Learning is a win/win for employers and employees. Learning-driven organizations tend to be more efficient, create more customer value and market leadership, and report higher customer satisfaction. Employees of all ages, especially Millennials, see re-skilling and upskilling as critically important, and often it’s the deciding factor in their decisions to take a new job or stay at their current company.In Paycor’s Guide, “3 Reasons to Invest in a Learning Culture,” you’ll learn how to invest in and build a learning culture. You’ll also learn the “why behind the what,” and see firsthand how your company’s learning impacts your ability to recruit, retain and engage talented people.Download Paycor’s Guide for actionable tips and insights...

Case Study: Shelba Johnson Trucking

Case Study: Shelba Johnson Trucking

After experiencing numerous implementation challenges and unreliable customer support Shelba Johnson Trucking had enough and began searching for a reliable HR and payroll provider. Read the case study below to learn how Paycor’s HCM platform helped eliminate manual processes and offer supervisors more visibility into hours worked and time off requests.“Whether it was working with sales or implementation, I’ve always felt confident with my Paycor team. They’ve never made empty promises and always go out of their way to help us. - Carol Agee, Director of HR Why Shelba Johnson Trucking Left Their HR & Payroll Provider Shelba Johnson Trucking transports furniture across the entire eastern United States and Texas. When their previous HR...