Payroll Errors: 12 Common Mistakes You Might Be Making
Payroll Errors: 12 Common Mistakes You Might Be Making

Payroll Errors: 12 Common Mistakes You Might Be Making

Payroll Matters

The payroll process is a necessary component of any business and making sure it’s accurate is exceptionally important. Even the smallest error can have a lasting impact on your company’s bottom line when you consider penalties, fines, and even lawsuits. This can be a nuisance to mid-size businesses but devastating to a small business.

It’s Hard to Go Unnoticed

The Department of Labor (DOL) keeps a close eye on businesses to help ensure they pay their employees correctly, and the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) and state taxing authorities are always going to make sure they receive the appropriate tax payments.

12 Common Errors to Avoid

Everyone makes mistakes, and we’re hopeful they’re caught before anything bad happens. But it’s imperative to make sure that you’re not making any of these relatively common payroll mistakes if you manually calculate payroll in-house.

  1. Misclassifying employees and contractors
  2. In the gig economy, temps, freelancers, consultants and other independent contractors are commonly found in many industries. It’s essential that you accurately categorize everyone who works at your business, so you can properly report your payroll taxes to taxing authorities.

  3. Miscalculating exempt and non-exempt employees
  4. You must follow pretty strict guidelines when determining who gets overtime pay; miscalculations can hit you hard. In recent years, more and more employees are suing their employers claiming they didn’t receive overtime pay they were entitled to because they were incorrectly classified as exempt employees. It’s important to keep a close watch on this one.

  5. Miscalculating overtime
  6. If employees still use paper time cards and you manually run your company’s payroll, it’s easy to make data entry mistakes when it comes to overtime pay. Make sure to check and double check all numbers so you don’t pay someone too much or short them on time.

  7. Failing to pay minimum wage
  8. Federal and state laws are in strict agreement for this one. You must pay employees at least the prevailing minimum wage for the regular rates of pay.

  9. Improper tax calculations
  10. Taxes are always changing and tough to keep track of, especially if you have locations in multiple states or jurisdictions. Monitoring changes can easily become a full-time job, but you’ve got to get it right or Uncle Sam will come knocking.

  11. Missed deadlines
  12. You know it’s important that you absolutely have to make payroll on scheduled paydays and make sure employees are paid on time. But you also need to mark your calendar to ensure that you report and deposit payroll taxes to federal and state agencies in a timely fashion. Making a late deposit can result in fines and interest charges.

  13. Failing to send 1099s
  14. Speaking of contractors, you have to send a Form 1099 to any independent contractor who’s paid $600 or more during the year by January 31st. Again, it’s important to mark this date on your calendar!

  15. Data entry errors
  16. Mismatching Social Security numbers and employee names is such a common occurrence that the Social Security Administration even provides Social Security number verification services. Other data entry errors, such as keeping inaccurate employee hours, can cost businesses millions of dollars every year and can also result in those pesky fines and penalties. If you’re processing your payroll manually, using payroll software can help, but you’ve still got to watch your entries.

  17. Improperly handling levies, garnishments or child support
  18. Sometimes employees owe money to other people as the result of a court order. This means whoever is managing payroll is responsible for deducting the appropriate amount and sending the payment to the appropriate recipient. If this process is mishandled, it could mean trouble for your employees.

  19. Not maintaining proper payroll records
  20. The rules vary depending on which state you’re in or which agency is asking for them, but typically all payroll records (time sheets, cancelled checks, and Forms W-4), must be stored for anywhere from four to six years.

  21. Not maintaining confidentiality
  22. Payroll information should never be disclosed to anyone outside of the payroll department, your senior management teams or your payroll service. It is important that such confidentiality be maintained.

  23. Not taking appropriate security measures
  24. Your payroll database contains a huge amount of personal information on your employees. So just like maintaining confidentiality within your department, payroll data must be stored in a secure environment. Whether you process payroll in-house, use a payroll service or payroll system, you’ve got to make sure that access is limited, you have strong passwords, and information is stored on secure servers with encrypted data.

Paycor Can Help

At Paycor, we’ve spent decades perfecting the payroll process. Our solution enables small and medium-size businesses to quickly and easily pay employees from wherever you are, all while ensuring tax compliance. Through 30 years of user feedback and product innovations, we’ve made payroll simple, so you can get in, make edits, run payroll and get out. Discover why nearly 30,000 organization are partnered with Paycor by talking with a representative today.


Paycor guided hr software tour

More to Discover

National Payroll Week Webinar Series: How to Prevent a Payroll Lawsuit - 9/9/20 @2pm ET

National Payroll Week Webinar Series: How to Prevent a Payroll Lawsuit - 9/9/20 @2pm ET

During National Payroll Week, Paycor is hosting three webinars to help business leaders prepare for compliance changes and new trends in 2021. In this webinar, we'll breakdown everything HR leaders need to know to avoid costly errors and payroll lawsuits.Speaker: Becky Stauffer Becky started her own consulting company Work4Accord, LLC where she serves National and Regional clients. Becky is a “Professional Encourager of Others”. She is active in communities that support professional growth including the SHRM, Society for Human Resource Management and the NSA, National Speakers Association.Becky holds a SPHR, Senior Professional in Human Resources, SHRM-SCP Senior Certified Professional and a Master’s in Public Administration from the...

National Payroll Week Webinar Series: Payroll Compliance Updates & What's Ahead in 2021 - 9/8/20 @2pm ET

National Payroll Week Webinar Series: Payroll Compliance Updates & What's Ahead in 2021 - 9/8/20 @2pm ET

During National Payroll Week, Paycor is hosting three webinars to help business leaders prepare for compliance changes and new trends in 2021.Register for any of the sessions below. From new salary thresholds and social security wage increases to COVID tax relief, businesses leaders have faced quite a few payroll and tax changes in 2020. As we prepare to turn the page to a new year, what new updates are on the horizon? Join Paycor’s resident payroll expert, Arlene Baker to learn about the latest updates and what you should watch out for in 2021.Speaker: Arlene Baker Arlene Baker is a Sr Compliance Analyst with over 40 years of payroll and tax experience. Arlene is a member of the National Payroll Reporting Consortium focusing on IRS...

How to Calculate Overtime Pay for Tipped Employees

How to Calculate Overtime Pay for Tipped Employees

Calculating overtime pay can be a challenge at the best of times, and when you’re dealing with tipped employees it can turn into a real headache. The problem is, many employers assume that overtime is calculated the same for their tipped employees as everyone else. That’s not the case, but it’s important that businesses get it right—or they’ll have dissatisfied employees and the Department of Labor on their backs. The good news is, Paycor Payroll automatically calculates overtime pay so our clients can stay compliant without worry. However, it’s still good practice for all employers to understand how calculating tipped employees overtime pay works. Let’s go step-by-step. Who Is Considered a Tipped Employee? A tipped employee is anyone...

Understanding the Supreme Court Ruling on LGBT Workplace Discrimination

Understanding the Supreme Court Ruling on LGBT Workplace Discrimination

Understanding the Supreme Court Ruling on LGBT Workplace Discrimination A recent Supreme Court judgement is being celebrated as a landmark moment in the fight for workplace protections for LGBT workers. This has confirmed in federal law what was already established in many states: that all employers should avoid LGBT discrimination in the workplace. Let’s break down the next steps for employers. What The Ruling Means for Businesses The ruling means that is officially illegal for employers to fire, refuse to hire or discriminate regarding pay and conditions of employment based on an employee’s sexual orientation or gender identity. Those who breach the law could face costly penalties, though it’s important to note that the relevant...