Understanding the Supreme Court Ruling on LGBT Workplace Discrimination
Understanding the Supreme Court Ruling on LGBT Workplace Discrimination

Understanding the Supreme Court Ruling on LGBT Workplace Discrimination

Understanding the Supreme Court Ruling on LGBT Workplace Discrimination A recent Supreme Court judgement is being celebrated as a landmark moment in the fight for workplace protections for LGBT workers. This has confirmed in federal law what was already established in many states: that all employers should avoid LGBT discrimination in the workplace.

Let’s break down the next steps for employers.

What The Ruling Means for Businesses

The ruling means that is officially illegal for employers to fire, refuse to hire or discriminate regarding pay and conditions of employment based on an employee’s sexual orientation or gender identity.

Those who breach the law could face costly penalties, though it’s important to note that the relevant legislation only applies to companies with 15 or more employees.

In reality, employers should not have to change how they operate. Not only did many cities and states already have legislation protecting LGBT people from discrimination, but the law in question—Title VII of the Civil Rights Act—was already being interpreted by the body who enforces it—the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC)—as extending to sexual orientation and gender identity.

However, the full implications of the ruling may not be known until there are further court rulings later down the line. Employers should be alert for updates on addition consequences of the decision.

How to Avoid Discrimination of LGBT in the Workplace

All employers should ensure they understand what counts as discrimination and take care to educate all employers on these issues. If they haven’t already, companies should adapt their employment policies to explicitly forbid discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity.

But that’s not all. Businesses should also review all workplace procedures to identify any areas where LGBT employees could be at risk of discrimination. This includes hiring and firing but extends to benefits plans, leave policies and insurance offerings. The more rigorous your review the more certain you can be not only that you are compliant but that you are offering an inclusive working environment for all LGBT employees.

The Supreme Court Ruling

Now, let’s break down exactly what was decided in more detail. On Monday June 13, the Supreme Court ruled that civil rights laws protect against workplace discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation or gender identity. The consequence for employers is that it is now illegal under federal law to fire an employee because they are gay or transgender. While some jurisdictions already legislated against this, more than half of states had no such protections.

The relevant legislation—Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964—protects against discrimination on the basis of “race, color, religion, sex, or national origin”. The key term in this decision is “sex”—as author of the decision Justice Gorsuch wrote, “it is impossible to discriminate against a person for being homosexual or transgender without discriminating against that individual based on sex."

Until this definitive judgement, it had been unclear whether the term “sex” extended to cover all cases concerning discrimination of LGBT in the workplace.

The Judgement Explained

Justice Gorsuch explained the ruling using the following examples: “Consider, for example, an employer with two employees, both of whom are attracted to men. The two individuals are, to the employer’s mind, materially identical in all respects, except that one is a man and the other a woman.

If the employer fires the male employee for no reason other than the fact he is attracted to men, the employer discriminates against him for traits or actions it tolerates in his female colleague.

Or take an employer who fires a transgender person who was identified as a male at birth but who now identifies as a female. If the employer retains an otherwise identical employee who was identified as female at birth, the employer intentionally penalizes a person identified as male at birth for traits or actions that it tolerates in an employee identified as female at birth.”

Paycor is Here for You

Paycor builds HR software for leaders of medium & small business. For 30 years, we’ve been listening to and partnering with leaders, so we know what they need: HCM technology that saves time, powerful analytics and expert HR advice to help them solve problems and achieve their goals. Take a self-guided tour of our software and see for yourself.

Take Tour

More to Discover

Webinar: Compliance Matters: Layoffs, Furloughs, and Recalls - 11/19 @2pm ET

Webinar: Compliance Matters: Layoffs, Furloughs, and Recalls - 11/19 @2pm ET

A top concern of HR departments is how to effectively manage layoffs, furloughs and recalls as a result of COVID-19. Register for our upcoming webinar as Kara Govro, attorney & HR expert, addresses the compliance around navigating these difficult decisions. During this 60-minute webinar, Kara will also answer your questions about COVID-19 related issues impacting your small business. Register now! Speaker: Kara Govro Kara Govro is a Senior Legal Editor for Mammoth HR and been with Mammoth HR for over 5 years.Thursday, November 19 2pm ET

Termination Letter to Employees [Template]

Termination Letter to Employees [Template]

When an employee is let go, it’s only natural that you’ll want to tell them the news in person. Just as important, though, is providing written confirmation. Termination letters to employees offer a chance to set down the important details a departing employee needs to know—but getting the tone right can be tricky. It’s all too easy to go into unnecessary detail or, worse, avoid uncomfortable truths. Download Termination Letter Template How to Write a Termination Letter to Employees A termination letter has several functions. Firstly, you’re letting an employee know the reasons why they have been terminated. Often this news can be easier to digest when written down. Secondly, you are giving an employee confirmation of the timings and...

California Labor Laws: How to Stay Compliant

California Labor Laws: How to Stay Compliant

California offers business incredible opportunities—if it were a country, it would have the 5th largest economy in the world. But HR leaders operating in the Golden State face notoriously complicated and ever-evolving labor laws. Failing to meet labor standards means heavy fines and the risk of class actions, so finding a way to get (and stay) compliant isn’t optional.In Paycor’s latest report, we break down the 6 California labor laws you need to know and how Paycor can help keep you compliant.

Webinar: A Sexual Harassment Avoidance Program

Webinar: A Sexual Harassment Avoidance Program

In 2018, the number of workplace sexual harassment claims hit a 10-year high. With more attention from the #MeToo movement and heavily enforced state and federal regulations, employers are wondering how they can not only protect their business but their employees as well.In this webinar, Peter Newman, a labor and employment attorney, will provide a 14-step action plan designed to prevent sexual harassment in the workplace.Speaker: Peter NewmanPeter Newman is a “switch hitting” employment lawyer representing both employers and employees in all areas of employment law and related litigation. Peter has extensive experience with NLRB and Ohio SERB representation and unfair labor practice matters. In addition, Peter is a corporate compliance...