3 Key Traits of a Successful Recruiter
Traits of a Successful Recruiter

3 Key Traits of a Successful Recruiter

Our Recipe for Hiring Great Recruiters

Hiring the Wrong Recruiter Can Be Catastrophic

A bad hire can be costly, but the costs of hiring a bad recruiter can be catastrophic. The ripple effect of one bad hire can send waves of consequences throughout your organization that leads to significant losses in money, employee morale, and organizational productivity. When that one bad hire happens to be the person who will be making your hiring decisions going forward, the direct and indirect costs of this ripple effect are compounded exponentially.

Hiring a Catalyst

When considering the gravity of these consequences, the task of hiring a recruiter can be daunting. However, remember that with great risk, comes great reward. Just as detrimental as a bad recruiter can be, a great recruiter can be the difference maker, serving as a “catalyst” for an organization’s success.

So how do you wade through the vast sea of recruiters to recruit a “catalyst recruiter?” The first thing that you must consider is that recruiters know this game better than anyone else. They have spent their careers training and coaching others on how to interview well, and through this experience, they know all of the tricks of the trade. Any recruiter will be able to leverage their strengths and mask their weaknesses in a way to appear qualified for a given job. For this reason, when interviewing for a recruiter, you have to double down and be prepared to carry out an in-depth assessment. Below, we cover one aspect of this assessment process, providing an overview of the three traits that you must ensure that your recruiting candidates possess.

  1. Resourcefulness

  2. The number one trait that constitutes any good recruiter is resourcefulness. For this reason, we like to say that a truly successful corporate recruiter must be the “MacGyver” of your company. It takes this kind of “jack-of-all-trades” to transverse departmental lines, understand the functional needs of drastically different roles, and effectively sell a diverse range of candidates on these given roles.

    To add to this dynamism, over the past decade we have seen an evolution of the talent acquisition industry. Almost all of the typical recruiting functions have shifted online and are now embedded in new forms of technology. It is no longer enough to be a good “people person” or an “email wizard.” The modern recruiter needs to be self-sufficient enough to pick-up the various tools, systems, and methods at their disposal to optimize their efforts and save the day.

  3. Confidence

  4. You know the saying, “it takes 9 no’s to get 1 yes?” There are few circumstances where this adage is more applicable than corporate recruiting. Literally, 90% of your time is spent failing. From people hanging up on you, to last minute offer rejections, being a recruiter is filled with demoralizing defeats. To add to this, recruiting is a thankless job. When things go wrong, the recruiter is often the first person to take the blame. Amidst all of this blame, recruiters very rarely receive any praise for a job well done. All of this negativity can crush even the most consummate professionals. For this reason, recruiters need superhuman confidence to avoid getting lost amongst the emotional peaks and valleys of the job.

  5. Focus

  6. The last trait that must be hard-wired into the DNA of every recruiter is focus, and for three reasons. The first is that talent networks that were once closed and proprietary are now wide open. As a result of this, the best recruiters need the focus to get the right information fast and use it in an efficient manner to drive their decisions.

    Another reason every recruiter needs laser focus is that they often get pulled in a million directions at once. Hiring managers from every department will be tugging at a recruiter’s arm, trying to get them to find the perfect candidate for a multitude of different roles. It takes strong focus to prioritize these needs and fulfill them accordingly.

    The last reason that every recruiter needs to possess advanced focus capabilities, is that many corporate recruiting roles lack a traditional form of leadership. This is especially true for SMBs, where recruiters operate as their own department, or as a distant branch of HR. Under such circumstances, it is essential that recruiters have the focus to stay the course and keep the end goal in sight.

Hire Faster & Smarter with Paycor Recruiting

Finding, interviewing and hiring talented people are the most important challenges growing businesses face. Paycor Recruiting is a software solution designed and built by recruiters for recruiters and HR hiring teams to help you solve your hiring problems and optimize your recruiting process.


recruitment software

More to Discover

Paycor’s streamlined HR and Payroll solutions coupled with a flexible Recruiting platform impressed Taste Buds Management

Paycor’s streamlined HR and Payroll solutions coupled with a flexible Recruiting platform impressed Taste Buds Management

Pandemic Response Paycor’s immediate product updates in response to new coronavirus legislation helped Michelle stay compliant and keep track of employees. “From a technical standpoint, being able to put someone on furlough in the system was great,” she said. “You created custom codes – that makes a big difference. Before it was either you’re hired or you’re not. Now, I’ll be able to sort these specific dates and it will help me make more informed decisions.” “We didn’t know how to handle COVID-19 and Paycor very quickly figured it out. As a partner, you definitely stood out as an authority—you navigated the messiness and gave us direction. Whatever you’re doing to keep your staff focused on the client, it’s working. You have a winning...

Virtual Interviews: Best Practices for Remote Recruiting

Virtual Interviews: Best Practices for Remote Recruiting

Remote recruiting makes everyone a little nervous, at least at first. Conducting interviews by video conference just doesn’t sound appealing—can you really read someone’s body language on video? What if the internet connection is bad? All these obstacles and more might make you long for the days when in-person interviews were the norm. But don’t give up on remote recruiting. Here’s how to make it better. The Benefit of Virtual Interviews Remote recruiting has advantages. It’s cost-effective, saves time and broadens your pool of candidates to include people who live out of state or even out of the country. If you commit to remote hiring, there’s no reason for it to be any less effective than in-person interviews. Before the Remote...

How to Achieve Diversity in the Workplace

How to Achieve Diversity in the Workplace

Cultural Diversity Organizational Diversity Diversity in Recruiting Elevate Onboarding Defining Diversity and Why It Matters Having tough conversations about diversity and working towards a more inclusive environment is a part of any successful business. But what, exactly, is diversity? We define diversity as understanding, accepting, and valuing differences in races, ethnicities, genders, ages and more. Diversity can also include recognizing and respecting differences in education, skill sets, abilities and experiences. In order to address diversity in the workplace, you have to be intentional. You have to get comfortable with being uncomfortable and accept that achieving diversity isn’t easy. But it will be worth it in the long run—a...

Take Our HR Benchmarking Quizzes

Take Our HR Benchmarking Quizzes

Paycor's research shows that 75% of high-functioning HR teams spend their time on mastering key pillars of HR excellence. Want to know how your team stacks up against others? Take our benchmarking quizzes to find out and get customized action plans based on your results. Recruiting Benchmark Quiz Benefits Benchmark Quiz Labor Costs Benchmark Quiz People Management Benchmark Quiz Compliance Benchmark Quiz