3 Tips to Fix a Broken Recruiting Process
3 Tips to Fix a Broken Recruiting Process

3 Tips to Fix a Broken Recruiting Process

Finding and hiring the right candidate can feel like a roller coaster ride for recruiters and hiring managers. Excitement levels fly off the charts once you’ve found and offered a job to your dream candidate, but if that candidate reveals they’ve decided to take their talents elsewhere, excitement quickly turns to disappointment. The chances every top candidate will accept your offer is a bit unrealistic, but it becomes a real problem for the health of your organization if you’re constantly striking out and failing to hire great people.

Unsure why candidates keep turning down your job offers? Consider your recruiting process. It’s often the leading contributor why organizations fail to find the right people for key positions. While many organizations are quick to blame talent shortages, it’s only an excuse for a broken recruiting process that needs to be evaluated. Keep reading for three ways to help fix the problem.

Proper Preparation Prevents Poor Interviews

Are you recruiters going through the motions or developing a plan to interview quality candidates for open positions? It starts with collaborating with the hiring team. This team must work with recruiters before a job is ever posted to fully understand the requirements of the position and prioritize skills that are required versus desired. By setting proper expectations, you’ll prevent recruiters from embarking on a wild goose chase that could frustrate candidates and leave them with a negative impression of your brand. Plus, the more detailed and precise the job description, the faster recruiters can identify candidates that meet the required skill set and eliminate a long, drawn-out interview process.

It’s a Group Effort

Is the bulk of recruiting falling solely on the shoulders of one person in your organization? Hiring should not be a one man or woman show – that’s a lot of pressure and responsibility to handle. The interview process should be collaborative and involve not just a manager and recruiter, but colleagues who will work with the individual. It’s critical for others to meet the candidate, ask questions and determine how they fit the culture of the organization. By offering all parties the opportunity to interview and evaluate the candidate, you’ll ensure that you’re making the best choice not just for the position but for the entire department.

Collect Meaningful Interview Feedback

Once you’ve completed an interview, how are you collecting feedback on candidates? And do you know the tendencies of your interviewers? If you’re exchanging emails or comparing notes in person, you’re not taking a strategic approach to hiring. To achieve better hiring decisions and collect accurate feedback on candidates, interviewers should incorporate hiring scorecards in the recruiting process. These scorecards can be a key differentiator for employers in managing recruiting because they provide an average score per interviewer for each candidate. Why is this so important? Consider this: Sally always gives 2’s but suddenly gave the latest candidate a 5. That’s a great indication that the candidate is above and beyond Sally’s standards. Or if Tim always gives high praise to candidates but suddenly gives a 2 – that’s a red flag that something must have gone wrong in their interview. When it comes to collecting meaningful interview feedback, understanding how your interviewers operate is key.

No one said recruiting is easy. But if you consider the importance preparation, communication and collecting feedback play in the process, you’ll increase your chances of hiring top talent. To eliminate the time and stress often associated with choosing a new applicant tracking system, we have developed a guide explaining everything that you should look for and expect while selecting a system. Click here to download our guide. Be sure to also download our Job Offer Letter Template to help streamline your hiring process.

More to Discover

EEO Compliance: Are You Prepared to File the Updated EEO-1 Report?

EEO Compliance: Are You Prepared to File the Updated EEO-1 Report?

On April 25, 2019 a federal judge announced a ruling that will require employers to collect 2018 employee pay data and hours worked by race, ethnicity and gender and submit it to the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) by September 30, 2019. On May 1, 2019, the EEOC decided that they will collect 2017 pay data in addition to the 2018 pay data that was previously announced. The EEOC is expected to open the portal for employers to submit 2017 and 2018 pay data beginning on July 15, 2019. Note: Employers are still required to submit component 1 of the EEO-1 form by May 31, 2019. What are the new EEO-1 reporting requirements? The current EEO-1 form requires company employment data to be categorized by race, ethnicity, gender and...

Industry Spotlight - Manufacturing: Minding the Skilled Talent Gap

Industry Spotlight - Manufacturing: Minding the Skilled Talent Gap

80% of manufacturers are concerned about meeting workforce demands over the next five years. As the gap between skilled labor available and the number of jobs open continues to grow, top manufacturing firms are exploring proactive ways to streamline their hiring processes, improve employee training and growth and increase overall retention. In this webinar we will explore HR trends affecting the Manufacturing industry and discuss some of the strategies that leaders are taking to stay ahead of the latest trends in the current landscape. Speaker: Henry Link Henry is a Senior Marketing Program Manager at Paycor. Henry has been instrumental in the ideation of the HR Center of Excellence which is an action plan grounded in data, experience...

Fall In Love with your Hiring Process

Fall In Love with your Hiring Process

Hiring the perfect candidate starts with your hiring process. In order to make sure candidates fall in love with your company and you hire the best person for the job you need a simple, structured process. Join Andrea Buschmiller, Senior Recruiter at Paycor on Wednesday, February 27th and learn the steps you can take to hire the perfect candidates for your open roles and avoid making a toxic hire. Andrea is a Senior Recruiter at Paycor. Since graduating from Ohio University in 2009 she has spent 5 years in the talent acquistion space, specifically in marketing, creative and sales. Andrea has been at Paycor for 2.5 years recruiting for their high velocity sales team. Outside of Paycor Andrea enjoys travelling, working on non-profit boards...

Rise Above the Status Quo: An Executive Summary

Rise Above the Status Quo: An Executive Summary

Our Biggest and Best Web Summit Yet! More than 18,000 people registered for Paycor’s two-day online Rise Web Summit, held in February, where industry experts offered advice on all things HR, from employee engagement to hot button compliance issues. If you didn’t get a chance to watch the webinars live, feel free to watch them on-demand. In the meantime, here’s a quick overview of each session and some of the key takeaways. The Future of HR Now more than ever, executives depend on the unique insights HR can bring to the table. However, there is a problem. Many HR leaders just aren’t thinking big enough. Our keynote speaker, DisruptHR’s Jennifer McClure, outlined four key strategies HR leaders can use to push past their comfort zones and...