Background Check Strategies and Trends
Background Check Strategies and Trends

Background Check Strategies and Trends

There’s a lot changing in the world of HR between technology advances and shifting regulations, and the fundamental details of the hiring process are changing, too. Included under that are new trends, capabilities, and laws regarding background checks and how to perform them.

Les Rosen, CEO, and Dawn Standerwick, Vice President of Strategic Growth, both with Employment Screening Resources, lent their expertise to Paycor’s March 10 Web Summit and gave a thorough rundown of things to keep an eye out for in the year ahead.

The importance of due diligence

Each hire you make carries with them a certain level of risk. Despite all your vetting and interviewing, as an employer, you must have faith that new employees will be a positive, productive, long-term member of your workforce.

The threat of hiring an applicant who ends up underwhelming you isn’t as bad as the danger of negligent hiring. If you fail to identify certain red flags before bringing someone in and that new hire causes serious harm (such as workplace violence, theft, or property damage), you as the employer are not only liable, but you could be sued. This type of litigation is something we’ve seen a lot more of in recent months.

There’s a big, scary list of bad outcomes that can result from failing to do your due diligence before hiring:

Workplace violence (not always the worst-case scenario, but assaults or physical altercations)

* Time wasted in the process of recruiting, hiring, and training

* Money wasted as a result of unnecessary employee turnover

* Lawsuits for negligent hiring, retention, promotion, or supervision

* Erosion or destruction of brand reputation, customer-brand relations, and positive corporate culture

* Hiring someone with false credentials or qualifications (it’s estimated that a whopping 40 percent of résumés contain falsifications or important omissions regarding education or experience)

The danger of being too thorough

On the other hand, there’s some detriment to employers trying to gather too much information. Privacy laws and regulations are becoming more prominent grounds for lawsuits. If the background check or application process is too invasive, a company can be hit with litigation for violating the guidelines of the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA).

FCRA lawsuits can really hurt because they can easily and quickly turn into a costly class action lawsuit. Commonly, these lawsuits draw around $1,000 in damages per plaintiff, with the company also having to pay for attorney’s fees and court costs. This has happened to a lot of notable and visible companies over the past year, including Whole Foods, Amazon, and Home Depot.
What’s an employer to do?

The critical action behind this treacherous tightrope walk is to protect the reputation of individuals while preventing discrimination. For employers and hiring managers, this puts greater pressure on them to perform background checks properly and respectfully.

Recent state legislation has led to 18 states passing “Ban the Box” laws, which prohibit companies from asking applicants about their past criminal record on applications with a simple check-yes-or-no question. The idea is that it can cause such an applicant to be removed from consideration without giving them a chance to provide details regarding convictions or their rehabilitation.

If they need to comply with new “Ban the Box” rules, employers should wait until they’ve decided to interview and/or hire a candidate before asking about their criminal history. At the same time, “Ban the Box” has become enough of a trend that employers should consider proactively removing this question from their job applications, even if their state hasn’t passed “Ban the Box” law yet. Instead, companies should use a credible consumer reporting agency further along in the hiring process, share their findings with applicants, and then allow for them to offer some explanation of their circumstances.

Rather than denying all applicants with a criminal past, employers should instead use a more detailed set of metrics to assess these applicants:

* Analyze the nature of the crime, the harm caused, and the level of the offense

* Consider the amount of time since the offense and conviction and whether the applicant has avoided problems in the time since

* Factor in the nature and duties of the job for which the candidate is applying and whether it is likely to be affected by their criminal background

Evaluating candidates with some sort of criminal record requires assessing individual situations and respecting people’s efforts to improve after past mistakes. There are likely more important factors in hiring than whether a person has a conviction from their past hanging over their head. Hiring managers should make a concerted effort to hire candidates that will benefit the company, its existing employees, and the invididual.

This content came from a March 10 Paycor webinar. Missed Paycor’s Web Summit or want to hear this webinar as it happened live? Click over to our webinar recordings page. And, contact us if you need to refresh your background check strategies.


Subscribe to Our Resource Center Digest

Enter your email below to receive a weekly recap of the latest articles from Paycor's Resource Center.

Check your inbox for an email confirming your subscription. Enjoy!

More to Discover

Payroll Risks and Controls: Everything You Need to Know

Payroll Risks and Controls: Everything You Need to Know

Believe it or not, running payroll is a risky business The IRS estimates that 40% of small to medium-size businesses end up paying a payroll penalty each year. Whether you’re a large organization or a small one, there’s always a risk of payroll errors leading to fines, penalties and sometimes litigation. Protect yourself from fraud and human error Businesses that run payroll on their own, especially small businesses, are at a much higher risk of being disrupted by fraudulent activity and human error. From ghost employees to hour padding to buddy punching, when a company lacks the appropriate internal controls to manage its payroll, it can run into big trouble. Here are 6 common payroll risks and controls you can implement to mitigate...

401(k) Match Limits 2019: What Payroll Administrators  Need to Know

401(k) Match Limits 2019: What Payroll Administrators Need to Know

It’s a relatively small change, but it’s a change for payroll administrators to take notice of. As of November 2018, your employees’ contribution limits for their 401(k) increased to $19,000 from $18,500. The increase raises the total annual contribution amount (employee plus employer contribution) to $56,000 or 100% of the employee’s salary if they make less than that. Most companies typically offer 3-6% in matching funds, but there is no limit to the amount an employer can contribute as long as the annual cap isn’t reached. 2018 & 2019 401(k) Match Limits Defined Contribution Plan Limits 2019 2018 Difference Maximum employee contribution $19,000 $18,500 +$500 Catch-up contribution for employees aged 50 or older $6,000 $6,000 No...

Webinar: October Web Summit - Compliance from Hire to Retire

Webinar: October Web Summit - Compliance from Hire to Retire

From managing recruiting compliance data to accurately tracking employee hours, you need a partner who can offer the right technology plus expertise to help mitigate risk. Register for this webinar to see how Paycor can help prepare you for all of the compliance challenges in managing the employee lifecycle!We will be reviewing these 4 major areas of compliance: Recruiting Hiring Payroll People Management Speaker: Brett BeilfussBrett has been the Senior Bank Marketing Program Manager for Paycor for the past three years. He works exclusively with Paycor’s Bank and CPA referral partners, whose aim is to help their clients mitigate risk.

Webinar: October Web Summit - How to Design your PTO and Paid Leave Policies

Webinar: October Web Summit - How to Design your PTO and Paid Leave Policies

As companies seek to offer employees more flexible work arrangements, designing paid time off and paid leave policies has never been more challenging. In this session, we will unpack the imposing array of federal, state and local laws that must be considered when designing lawful and effective PTO and paid leave policies.Speaker: Katharine WeberKatharine is a Principal in the Cincinnati, Ohio, office of Jackson Lewis P.C. She has successfully assisted countless clients in handling their labor and employment issues in both Ohio and Kentucky. Her expertise also includes litigating wrongful discharge cases, managing discrimination cases, negotiating collective bargaining and severance agreements, advising management on employment relations...