The Cost of HR Mistakes
The Cost of HR Mistakes

The Cost of HR Mistakes

Even if you’re running a small business without a dedicated HR department, there are plenty of HR issues you need to be aware of to avoid fines and penalties from government agencies. Recruiting and hiring employees, managing payroll, and employee management can be handled by a small business owner in a pinch, but there are plenty of details that are too easy to overlook when you’re trying to “do HR” on top of running your business.

Failures of compliance can be very costly, but they hurt even more if they could have easily been avoided in the first place. It is understandable that, for some small business owners, it’s not feasible to establish a true HR department because of lack of resources. A “do it yourself” HR strategy only works, however, if you have the foresight and resources to avoid the most common HR compliance mistakes before they happen.

Making poor hiring decisions

Identifying, recruiting, and hiring talent is time-consuming work that requires a particular set of skills—namely, very good people skills. The cost of a bad hire is steep when you factor in recruiting, training, benefits, and salary costs. In terms of actual dollars, a failed hire can cost you upwards of $50,000.

Hiring has exponentially more importance when your company is just starting out or has fewer than 50 employees. You’re building the foundation for continued success on these new hires: they are the people who will assume positions of leadership in your succession planning. All the more reason to get the right person for the job the first time around.

Misclassifying employees

Once you’ve hired the right employees, you have to ensure you adhere to the guidelines for classifying employees as put forth by the IRS. Some small businesses have cut corners on this and been punished severely when caught.

Most commonly, a small business can incorrectly categorize its workers in one of two ways. Some will declare employees as vendors or independent contractors, even though they don’t meet the guidelines for degree of company control and worker independence. To determine whether you are properly classifying an employee as a full-time employee or as an independent contractor, you should ask yourself the following questions:

* Does my company control when, what, where, and how the worker does their job?
* Are the means by which the worker accomplishes their work provided by my company? For example, how they’re paid and how the equipment needed for doing the job is provided to the worker?
* Does my company provide the worker with employee benefits? Is there a written contract specifying the nature of the company-worker relationship?

If the answer to each of these questions is yes, then that person cannot be classified as a independent contractor.

The second mistake employers make is classifying a salaried employee as exempt instead of non-exempt, thus preventing the company from having to pay overtime and break wages. This is even more crucial with the soon-to-arrive increase in the overtime exemption threshold, meaning more white collar employees will be eligible for overtime pay.

Not knowing the government regulations that affect you

Proper classification of employees is a large part of being compliant with Department of Labor regulations, but full compliance entails much more.

Part of this is knowing the specific guidelines of your industry. Certain things apply regardless—like securing protected health information—while other things are dependent on what products or services your company provides, whether it’s a food and beverage permit or environmental regulations for manufacturing.

The other aspect is providing your employees with the benefits that the federal government mandates based on your company’s size and number of full-time equivalent employees. Nationally, social security taxes, unemployment insurance, and workers’ compensation are required. Other elements, like medical leave and disability insurance, vary from state to state. As you likely know, the Affordable Care Act outlines the health care coverage employers are required to provide.

Failing to create corporate guidelines and policies

The previous points all had to do with the monetary cost of HR mistakes, each of which can cost you a lot of cash. But, much like how poor hiring can set your company back in other ways, failing to set policies for how employees should conduct themselves can hurt, as well.

Even smaller companies have to set clear guidelines and expectations for workers and hold them to those standards. This means handling training, performance evaluations, promotions, and firings in the right way. Not having policies for these items in place means risking unhappy employees and an uncertain future. Something as simple as creating an employee handbook can go a long way in terms of effectively controlling your employees’ behavior and preventing HR violations before they happen.

Running a business is hard. Paycor can help make it easier. Check out our other articles for entrepreneurs, or contact us to learn how we can help you stay in compliance with constantly changing government regulations like the Affordable Care Act and Fair Labor Standards Act.

Sources: Entrepreneur.com, IRS.gov, SBA.gov, HR Morning, Inc., UC Berkeley Haas School of Business


Subscribe to Our Resource Center Digest

Enter your email below to receive a weekly recap of the latest articles from Paycor's Resource Center.

Check your inbox for an email confirming your subscription. Enjoy!

More to Discover

DOL Final Overtime Rules: Quickstart Guide for Employers

DOL Final Overtime Rules: Quickstart Guide for Employers

On September 24, 2019, the Department of Labor issued its final overtime rule to increase the minimum salary threshold for executive, administrative and professional exemptions from $455 per week ($23,660 annually) to $684 per week ($35,568 annually). The new rule goes into effect January 1, 2020.As your organization considers how to prepare and comply, we’ve created this guide which outlines the new ruling, provides tips to manage impacted employees and offers a checklist of key details to follow to mitigate risk. Click below to instantly download the guide.

What are W-3 Forms? FAQs and Helpful Tips for 2020

What are W-3 Forms? FAQs and Helpful Tips for 2020

As a trusted HR & payroll provider, Paycor gets hundreds of questions about Form W-3 each year. To help HR professionals mitigate risk, our compliance experts answered the most frequently asked questions around Form W-3. What is a W-3 form? Technical answer: Form W-3 is used to total up all parts of Form W-2. Both forms are filed together and sent to Social Security Administration (SSA) every year. Form W-3 is also known as “Transmittal of Wage and Tax Statements.”What employers really need to know: As an employer your responsibility is to review all W-2s for your workforce, summarize employee wages and tax information and then combine that data into one W-3 form. What’s the difference between Form W-2 and Form W-3? The difference...

Employer Breastfeeding Laws by State

Employer Breastfeeding Laws by State

Breastfeeding, ACA and FLSA When President Obama made the Affordable Care Act (ACA) the law of the land in 2010, new amendments to the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) addressing breastfeeding in the workplace went into effect. The new guidelines require all employers in every state to provide reasonable break time for an employee to express breast milk for their nursing child for one year after the child’s birth. States are Making Changes While the federal government laid the foundation, 32 states have built upon the basic law. Some states have clarified whether these breaks are paid or unpaid and some have extended how long breastfeeding mothers are protected by the law.Where does your state stand? Use the chart below to find out....

Case Study: Smuttynose Brewing Company

Case Study: Smuttynose Brewing Company

Compliance concerns and a desire to streamline their overall HR process led Smuttynose Brewing Company in Hampton, N.H., to find HR & payroll software that suited their needs. With employees scattered throughout the Northeast, Smuttynose needed an efficient way to collect hours worked and to ensure payroll tax compliance. “Paycor is a one stop shop with great customer service and that service does not stop after implementation. I consider Paycor to be a true partner. I am extremely satisfied that I made the switch to Paycor and believe that satisfaction will only grow stronger as our partnership has a chance to mature.” —Mia Jennings, Director of HR, Smuttynose Brewing Paycor’s HR, recruiting and onboarding solutions streamlined a...