Hiring Independent Contractors: Are They Right for Your Business?
Hiring Independent Contractors: Are They Right for Your Business?

Hiring Independent Contractors: Are They Right for Your Business?

In today’s booming gig economy, it’s becoming more common for businesses to hire freelancers or contract workers instead of employees to supplement their existing workforce. Independent contractors can be brought on to fill just about any role within a company, from janitorial services to members of the C-suite.

Here’s the unique distinction: Independent contractors are self-employed and not considered a full-time employee of your company.

The pros and cons of hiring independent contractors

While this makes hiring freelancers attractive – knowing that the business is not responsible for additional overhead and equipment, payroll taxes, or benefits – you’ll also find some challenges and potential pitfalls that should be faced when you work with independent contractors. Here, we’ll go over a few of the pros and cons of making the decision to hire freelancers.

The 3 benefits of hiring a freelancer

  1. They can be a great resource during crunch times
    If you have certain times of the year when you’re extra-busy or if you’ve taken on new clients and need a helping hand with tasks so you can focus on business strategy, independent contractors can help. They can fill in the gaps where you need extra help. A freelancer can be a graphic designer, a writer, an accountant, IT support, an executive assistant, etc.
  2. They save you money
    Since these workers are not employees of the company, you’re not on the hook for paying benefits, state and federal taxes or worker’s compensation insurance. The independent contractor pays their own social security and Medicare taxes, as well as self-employment tax.
  3. Frees up your employees to focus on other projects
    When your employees aren’t weighed down by tasks and projects that are easily outsourced, they can focus more on supporting the business strategy, making the company more money.

The 3 downsides of hiring a freelancer?

  1. Less control
    The flip side of hiring someone as an independent contractor is that you lose the control that you have with your employees. For example, you can hire a graphic designer to create a corporate brochure, but you can’t tell them when to work on it or how many hours they must spend on it. You can require them to work onsite, but that can be a risky proposition if you start dictating the hours she should be in the office.
  2. Lack of continuity
    Even if you have a contract in place with a freelancer, they can always bail on you at any time. This could leave the status of that corporate brochure up in the air.
  3. Risk of misclassification
    This is the biggie when it comes to compliance with federal law. Is the person you just hired an employee or an independent contractor? If you have that freelancer working on-site, and you start dictating the hours she must be in the office as well as the software or methods she should use to create the brochure, you could be viewed as an employer. If you incorrectly determine whether a worker is an employee or contractor, you can really get into hot water with the IRS and Department of Labor (DOL).

Need help classifying employees? Check out this interactive worksheet.

4 tips to protect your business

  1. Ensure employees and contractors are properly classified
    Make sure you’re not exerting too much control as this could legally tip contractors into employee territory.
  2. Have a contract in place
    Contracts protect both you and the freelancer. Be sure you explicitly state in the independent contractor agreement that the working relationship is that of a business hiring a freelance worker. Be specific in the parameters of payment and deliverables. Include a non-disclosure clause to protect your company’s property.
  3. Make sure to have W-9s on file

    Always keep copies of Form W-9. If you work with a freelancer over a period of years, it’s okay to only keep the initial one (as long as the contract addresses the working timeframe), but it’s really best to request a new one each year.
  4. Make sure to file 1099s for contractors who earn more than $600 a year
    If you don’t, you could be in for a surprise in the form of IRS fines and penalties. And nobody wants that kind of heat.

Paycor can help

If you’re planning to hire an independent contractor, it’s important to take all the pros and cons into consideration. If you’re not sure about how to pay them or the potential compliance challenges surrounding hiring them, let’s talk. We’ve got decades of experience helping businesses classify employees and freelancers in every industry.


payroll software

More to Discover

What is a W-4 Form?

What is a W-4 Form?

What is a W-4 Form? W-4 forms are essentially very basic tax returns filled out by employees. Specifically, it tells employers the correct amount of tax to withhold from the employee’s paycheck. Need a W-4 Form? Download it here. Why are W-4s important? The accuracy of an employee’s W-4 submission will determine the size of their tax refund (or bill) at the end of the year. The amount withheld should be as close as possible to their actual tax obligation—a big deficit can be an unwelcome surprise and may be accompanied by further penalties. Withholding more than necessary is considered by some employees as an easy way to save but, while refunds may seem like a nice treat, you are taking away the chance for employees to invest (or use)...

Case Study: Price Brothers, Inc.

Case Study: Price Brothers, Inc.

A need for robust reporting tools and a modern HR and payroll platform with onboarding capabilities led Price Brothers, Inc., to Paycor. “We’re constantly hiring and looking for skilled trade help on a daily basis. Now they can fill out the application online and we can email them the new-hire paperwork. They can complete everything online before their first day.” - Kim McLaughlin, CFO, Price Brothers, Inc. Why Price Brothers, Inc., left their payroll provider Price Brothers, a Charlotte, N.C.-based plumbing contractor who specializes in new-home construction, needed a more modern HR and payroll platform that could keep up with their growing business. Their former solution wasn’t intuitive and didn’t collect all the data they needed for...

Case Study: Meeder Investment Management

Case Study: Meeder Investment Management

Adding Paycor Recruiting, Onboarding and Learning Management to their HR process helped Meeder Investment Management save time and increase employee engagement. “I love the ATS (applicant tracking system). It’s so easy to use. All the communication is right there. I can see manager feedback; I can see next steps. And then I click a button and all the [new hire] information seamlessly transfers to payroll. ” - Debbie Harris, HR Manager Prior to Paycor Meeder Investment Management, based in Dublin, Ohio, needed an automated recruiting, onboarding and LMS that integrated with their current system. Previously, they were tracking PTO by hand in Excel, manually entering new hire information and calculating paper timecards. Their LMS often...

FAQ: How to Hire People with Disabilities

FAQ: How to Hire People with Disabilities

Only 19.1% of disabled Americans are employed compared with 65.9% of the general population, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. Qualified job seekers with disabilities may be held back by companies’ fear of expensive accommodations or compliance regulations.If you’re interested in hiring people with disabilities, look no further. We’ve answered FAQs to help you remain complaint. Q: How does the federal government define "disability"? A: The concept of “disability” is defined by context. For employers, a person with a disability is someone who: has a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits one or more "major life activities," has a record of such an impairment, or is regarded as having such an impairment....