Is it Really That Complicated to Set Up Payroll for a Small Business?
Set Up Payroll for a Small Business

Is it Really That Complicated to Set Up Payroll for a Small Business?

Paying employees is one of the core responsibilities of any company. But the idea of setting up payroll for the first time is enough to cause nightmares for many small business owners. It’s not just that it takes time—it’s that small errors can come at a big cost to your business and run the risk of big fines from the IRS. The decision any small business owner has to make is whether to set up payroll all by yourself or get help. You might wonder, is it really so complicated? Let’s take a look at what setting up payroll will look like if you go it alone or if you choose to use a Payroll provider.

Setting Up Payroll Alone

First Steps

The reality is, doing it alone really is difficult—especially if you don’t have experience. The most challenging part is right at the start: you’ll first have to set up general ledger accounts to track your money and enable reliable bookkeeping. Next, you’ll have to choose your pay schedule, taking into account state law on pay periods. Employees love regular paychecks but the shorter the pay period the more work for employers who process payroll manually.

Information Gathering

Processing payroll requires many documents, starting with an Employer Identification Number (a “Taxpayer ID Number”), for which you’ll have to apply. Here’s a selection of other documents and data you’ll need to gather and (crucially) keep updated:

  • Employee addresses
  • Employee Social Security Numbers
  • Employee bank account info (if required for direct deposit)
  • W-4 forms (plus any applicable state withholding certificates)
  • W-9 (for any independent contractors)
  • I-9 forms
  • Workers Compensation ID Number
  • Medical insurance forms
  • Retirement plan documents

Tracking Time Worked

The steps listed so far, though tricky, are mostly ‘set and forget’: they don’t have to be repeated. However, there’s a lot you’ll have to do every single pay period—starting with precisely tracking the time worked by all hourly workers as well as all Paid Time Off, overtime and sick leave. To stay FLSA compliant, you’ll also need to make sure you’re paying all workers the minimum wage at all times.

Payroll Calculations

If you’re processing payroll manually, it’s time to get the calculator out. To calculate an employee’s net pay, you first have to calculate their gross pay, before all deductions and withholdings—taxes (local, state and federal), medical insurance, retirement contributions and more.


To make sure every detail is correct, you’ll want to run reports. If you’re taking the manual route this can be very time consuming, but it’s essential. You need to know exactly how much cash you have available, your total tax withholding and total tax liability. All payroll information—including employee wages, hours worked and overtime earned—must be tracked and stored for Department of Labor oversight.

Paying Employees

Finally, you’ll have to actually pay employees. You need to send direct deposits (at least 2 business days in advance of pay day), print and mail checks or, more rarely, distribute funds to payroll cards. You also need to make sure you pay all required taxes, on time and in full. In some states you will also need to give employees a physical pay stub.

Processing Payroll with a Payroll Provider

The biggest benefit of using a payroll provider is that the hardest steps—like setting up general ledger accounts, organizing your departmental structure and storing hoards of employee data—are done for you. Paycor streamlines the entire process so that every pay period you only need to confirm calculations are correct, rather than wasting hours on admin. Some of the key benefits include:

  1. A core HR solution which stores all relevant employee data and forms
  2. Time and attendance software with multiple time clock options to help you accurately track the hours employees work—and automatically import these for payroll
  3. A payroll engine that does all the calculations for you (with built-in tax expertise so you’re never caught out by new regulations)
  4. Instant reports so you can be sure everything is correct as well as gathering actionable insights into your business
  5. Payment processing: once you click ‘submit’ we take care of the rest, including automatic mailing, full-page pay stubs and a garnishment processing service

Paycor guided hr software tour

More to Discover

Small Business Guide to Switching Payroll Providers

Small Business Guide to Switching Payroll Providers

Small businesses are often afraid of switching payroll companies, but are they right to be? Sure, it can be stressful. Setting up payroll is complicated enough, so is a change really necessary? The reality is, getting payroll right is so important—even small errors can lead to big fines, angry employees and wasted hours putting things right—that sticking with a payroll provider that doesn’t work well for you just isn’t an option. Is Your Current Payroll Provider Offering Enough? It’s easy to be tempted to stick with what you know, regardless of the problems with your current payroll provider. Choosing to switch providers certain isn’t an easy decision—but ask yourself: Is time being wasted on repetitive admin tasks? Does payroll need to...

For our HR & Benefits Technology Partners: The State of American Business in 2021

For our HR & Benefits Technology Partners: The State of American Business in 2021

Paycor surveyed 2,600 leaders of medium and small businesses (your clients and prospects) to find out what they are thinking at the close of the year and how they’re planning for 2021. Paycor delivers these insights to our broker partners to help you better understand what your clients need from you at this critical moment. Here’s an executive summary of the report. For more, click on the download button at the bottom of the page. Part 1: Benefits A majority of your clients and prospects (86%) are concerned about mental health in the workplace, but nearly half (45%) are “not sure” how benefits can address these concerns. Part 2: The Finance/HR Relationship Roughly 40% of respondents agreed that HR and Finance are working more closely...

Webinar: Paycor Virtual Payroll Platform Overview - 12/22 @2PM ET

Webinar: Paycor Virtual Payroll Platform Overview - 12/22 @2PM ET

Focus on what you do best. We’ll take care of the rest, behind the scenes.Over the years, Paycor has conducted hundreds of user groups, one-on-one interviews, and group discussions with HR leaders. One thing we discovered is that HR teams spend nearly 70% of their time on inefficient administrative tasks, some of which are still paper-based. To make a difference in your organization, your team needs to simplify and streamline HR, benefits administration and compliance so you can focus on what you do best.Join us as one of our solution experts walks through how Paycor’s Payroll solution can help you solve some of your biggest HR challenges.Speaker: John RedingJohn is the Senior Director of Deal Success and Pre-Sale Support for Paycor. A...

Webinar: Look Forward Webinar Week - Wage and Hour 101 - 12/10 @2pm ET

Webinar: Look Forward Webinar Week - Wage and Hour 101 - 12/10 @2pm ET

This session is eligible for 1 HRCI and 1 SHRM credit.Understanding the basics of wage & hour requirements can help you avoid penalties, prevent lawsuits and promote healthy relationships with employees.Join us for our upcoming webinar as we introduce the basics of Wage & Hour requirements.Key topics discussed: - Basics of exempt versus non-exempt classification - Paying non-exempt employees - Recordkeeping requirements - Overtime and travel time considerationsSpeaker: Kara GovroKara Govro is a Senior Legal Editor for Mammoth HR and been with Mammoth HR for over 5 years. Thursday, December 10 2pm ET