Paper or Plastic? The Pros and Cons of Paycards
Paper or Plastic? The Pros and Cons of Paycards

Paper or Plastic? The Pros and Cons of Paycards

Paycards are an alternative method of paying employee wages—instead of payment via paper check or direct deposit, an employee’s pay is loaded onto a debit card each pay period. These cards eliminate the need for a traditional bank account and, in some states, can enable companies to go completely paperless when combined with direct deposit. Many employers have implemented a paycard system, but it’s important to weigh the advantages and disadvantages of paycards before making a decision to switch.

Using a paycard system

Generally, paycard systems work in the following way:

  • An employer establishes an account with a paycard program and deposits money into their account.
  • The program or its partner bank issues the paycards.
  • Employees receive a PIN and can use their card as if it were a traditional debit card.
  • Employees’ wages are deducted from the employer account and are loaded onto the paycard every pay period.

Employer costs depend on the volume of workers using the cards and fees imposed by the bank and the program. Employees may be charged fees including monthly fees, ATM fees and withdrawal fees depending on the program. But choose your provider carefully. Depending on which state your business is in, it may be illegal to charge fees to employees.

Naturally, the mention of so many potential fees has raised red flags surrounding the use of paycards. Because of this challenge, federal law requires businesses to offer at least one other type of payroll distribution (paper check or direct deposit) to its employees.

The case for paper checks

  • Paycards can turn out to be a costly option for employees. For example, the New York Times found that one provider charged $1.75 for ATM withdrawals, $2.95 for a paper statement, $6.00 to replace a lost or stolen card, and $7.00 for inactivity fees. Some companies even charge a fee for calling to check the available balance on the card.

  • Payroll laws in some states prohibit employers from compelling their workers to receive their pay in ways that cost them money, and some paycard systems do just that by collecting so many fees. Depending on the program, paycards may not necessarily reduce the processing costs for the business.

However, despite these criticisms of paycards, they can be an advantageous option for companies that partner with the right provider.

The case for plastic paycards

  • 22% of U.S. households in America today are considered “unbanked.” This means they do not have access to a mainstream bank account or the financial services it provides. These families cannot receive direct deposit payments.
  • By switching to paycards, many unbanked employees can save up to a week’s worth of salary they would have otherwise lost to the accumulation of fees such as payroll check cashing charges or penalties from payday lenders.
  • Employees can use paycards without a credit check or any bank account requirements.
  • Paycards and direct deposit can be cheaper than paper checks—by up to $3.15, according NACHA, The Electronic Payments Association.
  • For most employers, paycards are easy to set up and provide the benefit of safety and convenience.
  • Paycards allow companies to go mostly paperless, even if some of their employees do not have bank accounts.

Paycards can reduce payroll costs for employers and offer a convenient choice for employees. However, it’s important to research your options, understand the associated costs (for you and your employees), and create a plan to introduce the program to employees before you decide to implement paycards. Learn more about Paycor’s employee payment options, including secure and easy-to-use paycards.

Paycor guided hr software tour

More to Discover

Webinar: Virtual Demo: Employee Experience Solutions - 2/18 @1PM ET

Webinar: Virtual Demo: Employee Experience Solutions - 2/18 @1PM ET

Paycor’s human capital management software modernizes every aspect of people management, from the way you recruit, onboard and develop people, to the way you pay them, retain them and build a company culture. With a single source of truth for all employee data, you’ll never have to switch platforms, log-in to multiple systems, re-key information or open multiple spreadsheets. In this live virtual demo, our product experts will highlight Paycor’s Employee Experience Solutions, including HR, Learning Management and our mobile functionality. Discover how HR Leaders can build a great place to work where people show up, make a difference and win together. During the webinar, we’ll highlight how Paycor helps you: • Get out of the weeds and...

Webinar: 2021 COVID Culture – New Ideas for Leading Change - 2/25 @11AM ET

Webinar: 2021 COVID Culture – New Ideas for Leading Change - 2/25 @11AM ET

Are you curious about what you can do intentionally as a leader to improve your organization’s culture in the current environment? Showing employees that you care about them as people and not only as a producers of work, is critical during this time. In this webinar, we’ll be sharing ways to address the top 3 things employees often complain about: communication, leadership, and rewards or recognition (includes compensation and benefits). Learn practical steps you can put into action to improve including: - Proactively establishing a structure for new ways of working. - Conducting internal check-ins to learn more about work and employees’ personal needs. - Identifying employees deserving of recognition. - Continuously keeping the pulse on...

Webinar: Relationship Wellness Series: Navigating the Different Personalities at Work - 2/23 @2PM ET

Webinar: Relationship Wellness Series: Navigating the Different Personalities at Work - 2/23 @2PM ET

The differences in our ideas, backgrounds and personalities often strengthen the success of our teams. However, sometimes the differences can be a challenge. One simple way to enhance communication among the differences is to learn about each team member’s personality type. The purpose of this webinar is to help you easily identify personality types and better navigate successful relationships.In-depth personality type tools often require budget and lengthy training. In this webinar, our speakers will cover the following: - Learn a tool to help you self-assess your personality - Discuss the preferences of the different personality styles - Participate in exercises to help you better understand - Learn tactics to adapt to others’ styles...

Webinar: Relationship Wellness Series: A Case Study - Creating an Inclusive Workplace for Your Workforce - 2/11 @2PM ET

Webinar: Relationship Wellness Series: A Case Study - Creating an Inclusive Workplace for Your Workforce - 2/11 @2PM ET

What does #BLM mean to your organization? Responsible organizations are waking up to learn that it is more than a hashtag. Historically, systemic inequities brought to the surface by #BLM and other awareness groups have had a disparaging impact on minorities. Because the system of oppression is designed to protect itself after hundreds of years, we all have a lot to learn about how to make change. Attend this session and learn how one university IT Dept of 300 people changed their culture using assessments, planning, and gumption. They increased feelings of inclusiveness among their Black workforce, and their female workforce, and ultimately increased employee engagement and job satisfaction.At the end of this presentation, and through a...