The Case for Employee Background Checks (That Includes You, Small Businesses)
The Case for Employee Background Checks (That Includes You, Small Businesses)

The Case for Employee Background Checks (That Includes You, Small Businesses)

Hiring can be tough in this job market, and you may feel the pressure to move fast—whether to win a candidate before someone else does, because you desperately need the role filled, or simply because you need to get back to running your business. It can be tempting to trust your gut and skip a more thorough hiring process. But each employee represents a piece of your growing brand, and the results could affect the company for the long run. It’s worth doing things right.

Looking Ahead: The Risk of Skimping

Zappos CEO Tony Hsieh told Business Insider that as he reflected on the company, the biggest category of mistakes was in hiring: “If you add up the cost of our bad hires, and the bad decisions they made—and then, they in turn hire more bad hires—this whole domino effect over the past eleven years, it’s probably cost the company well over $100 million.”

For smaller businesses, there’s just no room to put that kind of money on the line.

We know that replacing a bad hire takes time and drains energy. Bad hires cost money in bad decisions—and in more extreme cases, in theft or lawsuits incurred. However, no risk is greater than that to brand, the one thing you truly can’t replace. As Warren Buffett famously said, “It takes 20 years to build a reputation and five minutes to ruin it. If you think about that, you’ll do things differently.”

All of us can think of brand scandals in the news generated by HR issues—Enron, Uber, Wells Fargo, to name just a few. Some companies have been able to come back from them eventually, but it is a very tough row to hoe. That process can be even tougher for a small company, without years of brand equity built up, or the resources or runway to invest in a comeback. As if these obstacles are not enough, it can also be hard for customers to disassociate problems from the rest of the company in a smaller operation. One bad hire can have a disproportionately devastating effect.

Due Diligence: Background Checks

When you consider these risks, it becomes clear that due diligence in your hiring is worth every penny. This starts with asking the right questions and vetting each candidate carefully, and includes investing in a high-quality background check.

What once felt like a formality is becoming industry standard. “Background screening wasn’t common in our industry 20 years ago,” said Greg, a manager at a boutique architecture and design firm. “Now I’d say about half our clients ask about it.”

And for good reason: In a 2016 survey, 8 in 10 companies reported that background checks helped them uncover information they wouldn’t have found otherwise. It might sound like a simple yes or no question of criminal history, but background screens offer so much more. Do you need to verify employment history? What about safe motor vehicle records for your new drivers? The information needed to establish trust and suitability for the job is different from business to business, and even role to role.

conduct-background-check-new-employee

How to Choose: Understanding the Difference

Starting a background check might sound intimidating, especially for companies without a robust HR department (or an HR department at all). That’s why today’s providers are adapting the way they work to make them more accessible to small businesses.

With the right background screen provider, the process is simple. Fortunately, it doesn’t have to be expensive or complicated, and it doesn’t require much prior knowledge.

Insist on compliance. Thanks to the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) and various state laws, candidates and employers have protections in place to respect boundaries. Trustworthy companies build hiring compliance right into the tool, so you don’t have to be an expert. Regulations vary by state (or even city) and by industry, so it’s worth finding a company that excels in compliance.

Make it thorough. Some screens simply check a national online criminal database, but perhaps surprisingly, that doesn’t tell the full story. There are jurisdictions or even states that don’t contribute criminal records to national databases at all. It’s important that your provider offers searches of primary sources—typically county-level criminal court records—as well as searching the most authoritative sex offender registry database, operated through the U.S. Department of Justice. Diane, an HR director in Seattle, considers the liability in the hiring process. “You can do a crappy check, but if it’s not thorough, you are still liable. You have to ask yourself: how much risk do I want to absorb?”

Find transparency and flexibility. On a provider’s web site, you should see exactly what the search entails, as well as options for add-on features. Look for clear pricing on the website and be wary of costly setup fees.

Skip the sales funnel. Modern screeners have self-service systems, allowing customers to get started right away—or whenever they choose—with no long sales calls or phone tag.

Solid background screening doesn’t need to be arduous or expensive. And it’s worth every second and penny it takes. You’ve worked hard to build your business and establish trust with your customers—there is no need to risk it all with a bad hire.


David Bloom, SterlingDavid Bloom is General Manager of the Small and Mid-Sized Business Group at Sterling, a global leader in employment background screening solutions. David was included in Entrepreneur Magazine's Brilliant 100 and on Business Insider’s list of 100 most interesting people in the NYC tech scene. His team recently launched the self-service SterlingNOW, a proud Paycor technology partner. SterlingNOW offers the same Sterling quality trusted by Fortune 500 companies, now tailored to the needs of smaller businesses. Within five minutes, you can set up an account and submit your first background check order, knowing that you’re getting a thorough screening you can trust.

More to Discover

What are Supplemental Unemployment Benefits?

What are Supplemental Unemployment Benefits?

Reductions in force are unavoidable in economic downturns, but are traditional severance packages the way to go? They can be a big hit to your company’s cash flow and are subject to payroll taxes. The tax-friendlier option, Supplement Unemployment Benefits plans (SUBS), can spread out costs and deliver the same value for the employee, too. How Do Supplemental Unemployment Benefits Plans Work? SUBs got popular in the ‘50s as a way to help workers in industries with cyclical employment patterns get a more steady income. SUBs were often fought for in collective bargaining agreements. They’re growing in popularity again across industries. Under a SUB plan, in the event of a Reduction in Force (RIF) or temporary unemployment due to training,...

Take Our HR Benchmarking Quizzes

Take Our HR Benchmarking Quizzes

Paycor's research shows that 75% of high-functioning HR teams spend their time on mastering key pillars of HR excellence. Want to know how your team stacks up against others? Take our benchmarking quizzes to find out and get customized action plans based on your results. Recruiting Benchmark Quiz Benefits Benchmark Quiz Labor Costs Benchmark Quiz People Management Benchmark Quiz Compliance Benchmark Quiz

Remote Work Policy - Information Security Template

Remote Work Policy - Information Security Template

To make remote work successful, HR needs to think through risk mitigation policies, especially if it’s new to your organization. One of the biggest issues to consider is information security. It’s important that your remote workers know what to do in case of a security breach or data loss. Download Remote Work Information Security Policy Template Why Information Security is Important for a Virtual Workforce Protecting your company’s data (and the data of your clients) is hard enough when everyone’s working in the same office. It gets more difficult in a distributed, virtual environment. When an employee is offered the opportunity to work remotely, you may want them to sign an initial work from home agreement covering the general...

COVID-19 ADA Requirements

COVID-19 ADA Requirements

UPDATE JUNE 22: Updated EEOC guidance states that “requiring antibody testing before allowing employees to re-enter the workplace is not allowed under the ADA”. What is the ADA? The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) is a federal law that provides protection to disabled workers. The ADA prohibits employers from discriminating against employees on the basis of a physical or mental disability. This legislation applies to any business with at least 15 employees and prohibits discrimination against those with disabilities in all aspects of employment. How does the Coronavirus pandemic impact ADA compliance? Short answer, we don’t know yet. The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA): The Basics The ADA broadly prohibits discrimination in...