The Pros and Cons of Flexible Work Arrangements
The Pros and Cons of Flexible Work Arrangements

The Pros and Cons of Flexible Work Arrangements

Back in the day, the primary determining factor for a candidate choosing your company over your competitors’ was salary. Nowadays, the tide is turning toward the employee benefits your company offers; specifically, flexible work arrangements. In fact, FlexJobs 2018 Annual Survey found that the top three factors today’s candidates look for in a job are:

  1. Work-life Balance
  2. Salary
  3. Flexible Work Options

what benefits job candidates want

Companies that offer flexible work arrangements reap big rewards, from access to top talent to increased retention rates. Enabling employees to work from home on a regular basis can also boost overhead cost savings when you’re not required to maintain office space for everyone. You’ll likely see improved attendance and productivity, as well as increased employee engagement when employees’ work days are more fluid, allowing them more freedom than that of a full-time position tethered to an office chair.

Offering a flexible work schedule to your employees is a highly appreciated perk. It gives them a greater say over their work schedules, so they can efficiently balance their work and family obligations.

According to a study conducted by the International Foundation of Employee Benefit Plans (Flexible Work Arrangements), 94% of employers surveyed said they provide some sort of flexible scheduling for their employees.

The most popular types of flex time are:

  1. Flexible hours for special situations (i.e. sick child or school event)
  2. Flexible workday start and quit times
  3. Telecommuting

best flex work benefits

The least popular flexible work arrangements included

  1. Seasonal Employment (32%)
  2. Summer Work Hours (32%)
  3. Job Sharing (19%)

But a flex time arrangement can also have its downsides. For example, when you have a distributed workforce, your business can be challenged by a lack of connection among team members. And when a team member works from home, lines between work life and home life will often blur causing managers to question employee productivity and actual hours worked. So, is it for your company? Let’s start with a few questions and considerations:

  1. Have your employees asked for flexible hours?
  2. If they have, carefully think through the potential implications. If your entire work environment is one that operates on shifts or requires a hands-on presence, of course, such scheduling wouldn’t work for you. But if your employees primarily work on computers (data entry, programming or technical writing, etc.) some flexibility in scheduling, compressed work weeks, or remote work for certain periods of time could be appropriate. For example, allowing employees to get to work at 9:00 and leave at 4:00 can help them avoid rush hour and improve their work/life balance and stress levels. Listen to your employees’ requests and see if it makes sense to implement a more generous policy.

  3. Are your employees self-directed?
  4. If they have difficulties completing their job requirements when they’re actually in the office, they sure won’t be successful working remotely. And a lot of people really enjoy the camaraderie of the office making a remote role isolating and unmotivating for them. It’s important to consider everyone in the company on a case-by-case basis rather than creating a blanket policy. And that leads us to the next question.

  5. If you implement flex scheduling, could you possibly run the risk of discrimination claims?
  6. As an example, you can’t have a policy offering flexible working arrangements to parents only. If you have a flexible work schedule, you’re required to apply the policy across the board (where it makes sense) so you don’t discriminate against protected groups.

  7. Have you carefully outlined the logistics of your flexible work schedule?
  8. It’s important that you have a formal written policy in your employee handbook that notes the details of the program, such as when employees must be in the office for meetings. You should also determine the hours employees should be available and accessible during the work day. Be sure to have your employees sign the policy to acknowledge that they will abide by the rules of the program. You should also specifically note that the flexible work arrangement is conducted on a trial basis and employees may be asked to return to an in-office schedule if it’s deemed that the flex work program isn’t working out with them.

  9. Would your business see any benefits from employing a flexible work arrangement?
  10. If company expansion has resulted in people being packed in like sardines, a telecommute policy for certain employees can eliminate the need for relocating to a bigger space.

Paycor Can Help You Manage Your People

Our HR solution helps you become more efficient, while connecting you with your employees through modern, intuitive solutions. From engaging employee self-service to unlimited workflows, Perform HR takes the burden off you and makes it easier to connect with your people. Your everyday processes become simplified, allowing you to focus on your most important work. To learn more, explore our HR and Benefits software.
paycor guided tour

More to Discover

Case Study: Boulder Country Club

Case Study: Boulder Country Club

Paycor’s enhanced implementation service model creates a fast start for Boulder Country Club. “The transition to Paycor has been amazing. The hands-on guidance and support they offered during implementation saved us so much time. Paycor took control of the entire process so I could focus on other things.” - Amber Maranya, HR Director, Boulder Country Club Prior to Paycor Boulder Country Club is a private club that serves 850 members across northern Colorado and offers everything from golf and tennis to fitness and swimming. Their previous HR & payroll platform was designed for small businesses and couldn’t easily track hours worked for commissioned employees. After evaluating multiple well-known providers, HR Director Amber Maranya...

If an Employee Tests Positive for COVID-19, Here’s What to Do

If an Employee Tests Positive for COVID-19, Here’s What to Do

Everyone needs a plan to fall back on if and when an employee gets sick or tests positive for COVID-19. Below you'll find the step-by-step guide on how your company should proceed if one of your employees tests positive for Coronavirus.Get Communication Letter Template to Use if Employee Tests Positive for COVID-19 6 Steps To Take If an Employee Tests Positive for COVID-19 Offer Support We’re all moving fast in this new world and it can feel like we’re flying blind, so this is just a reminder of what you already know: if an employee lets you know they’ve tested positive for COVID-19, take a moment to be there for them. As a leader of your company, there are of course professional limitations of what “being there” means—you won’t be able...

Emergency Sick Leave for Childcare: What Employers Need to Know About FFCRA

Emergency Sick Leave for Childcare: What Employers Need to Know About FFCRA

The Families First Coronavirus Response Act (FFCRA) is a big part of the government response to the current public health crisis, offering emergency sick leave and paid family medical leave to those affected by Coronavirus. Take a look at our guide on managing employee leave scenarios.The FFRCA doesn’t just apply to employees who are directly affected by the virus—those who are infected, caring for the infected or quarantined. It also puts in place measures for the parents or guardians of children whose schools or day care facilities are closed due to the pandemic.These measures will apply from April 1, 2020 through December 31, 2020. How Does the FFCRA Work for Parents? If an employee has been on payroll for at least 30 days and cannot...

Essential Business Letter (Template)

Essential Business Letter (Template)

Many states and cities are imposing complete or partial lockdowns, with most businesses forced to temporarily shut their doors or move to remote work and only “essential businesses” unaffected. This has left many employers and employees asking what exactly counts as an essential business.Download Essential Business Letter Template What Counts as an Essential Business? On March 19, the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA, overseen by the Department of Homeland Security) issued guidance on what business count as critical infrastructure. Some businesses are obviously essential—hospitals, pharmacies and law enforcement. The list is extensive—other essential businesses include stores selling supplies which allow people to...