These Are the 5 Must-Know Recruiting KPIs
recruiting kpis

These Are the 5 Must-Know Recruiting KPIs

Don’t Make a Recruiting Move without Having these Numbers in Mind

Fifty-five percent of HR teams feel extremely or very challenged in their search for high-quality talent. Finding the best person for the job has always been something of a challenge in the recruiting world, but it’s never been more difficult than it is in this new economy. The main complicating factor is the fact that unemployment numbers are historically low (as of early 2018) and there just aren’t as many job-hungry candidates as there used to be.

Ten years ago, there was a glut of applicants for almost every position. Depending on the role, it wasn’t uncommon to receive hundreds of résumés per position. Today is a completely different story, and recruiters have to really hustle (even more so than usual) to find the perfect candidate for the job. Of course, evolving to a data-driven team can take time. And, we all have our day jobs to contend with after all, but understanding which Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) are important and why is the first step on the path to recruiting excellence.

Big Data Is Everywhere

Including in recruiting, and it needs to be harnessed in order to help ensure you select the right employee for the job. It’s important to make data-driven hiring decisions. But how? Having a grasp of certain metrics can make the recruiting process easier and more effective. But, you need to dive deeper than just keeping a dashboard and a spreadsheet of how many résumés you’ve received or how many phone and in-person interviews you’ve conducted.

An International Public Management Association for Human Resources (IPMA-HR) survey indicates that more than two‐thirds of respondents collect HR metrics (69%), which is good news. Here are several KPIs that are 100% necessary to keep track of.

KPI #1: Offer Acceptance Rate

This metric will likely never hit 100%, but by tracking job acceptances over time you can see just how effective your talent acquisition strategies are. If your offer acceptance rate is low or on a downward trend, you need to make sure that your salaries and benefits are industry and location standard. This is the most important metric to have because the percentage of offers accepted is used to demonstrate the effectiveness of your company’s overall recruitment strategies.

KPI #2: Candidate Sourcing

This is an important metric for making decisions regarding your recruiting strategy and will inform several data points. Use this metric to determine how much and where to spend your recruitment budget (e.g., job fairs, on-campus recruiting, job boards); to determine recruiting hour allotment to recruitment resources, such as events; and to help determine recruiter performance.

KPI #3: Average Time to Fill

This metric is all about tracking the speed in which a candidate moves through your hiring pipeline once they’ve been recruited or have applied. Time to fill is pretty self-explanatory. It adds up the total number of days an open job goes unfilled. However, it can provide some telling information about how long recruiters take to contact a candidate after one is identified, as well as how long it takes to schedule an interview.

KPI #4: Current Candidate Pipeline

This metric is important for understanding which stage of the hiring process each candidate is in, as well as how many candidates are in each stage. It can answer several questions, such as: How many candidates in the interview state (i.e., “good” candidates) do you currently have? How many offers are outstanding? Which candidates will you close soon?

KPI #5: Reasons for Non-Selection

Keeping track of why a candidate wasn’t hired is important as well. Some reasons to include: Doesn’t meet qualifications (e.g., didn’t meet education or experience requirements, failed drug and/or background check); Candidate withdrew; Company not interested (e.g., the candidate had a poor interview, other candidates had more experience, bad references); and, Candidate declined offer. While not required, having this data can help with EEOC compliance in the event of discrimination litigation.

If you’re in search of more inspiration or best practices to take your recruiting process to the next level, check out a complete list of resources in the HR Center of Excellence Recruiting Hub.

More to Discover

Case Study: Meeder Investment Management

Case Study: Meeder Investment Management

Adding Paycor Recruiting, Onboarding and Learning Management to their HR process helped Meeder Investment Management save time and increase employee engagement. “I love the ATS (applicant tracking system). It’s so easy to use. All the communication is right there. I can see manager feedback; I can see next steps. And then I click a button and all the [new hire] information seamlessly transfers to payroll. ” - Debbie Harris, HR Manager Prior to Paycor Meeder Investment Management, based in Dublin, Ohio, needed an automated recruiting, onboarding and LMS that integrated with their current system. Previously, they were tracking PTO by hand in Excel, manually entering new hire information and calculating paper timecards. Their LMS often...

FAQ: How to Hire People with Disabilities

FAQ: How to Hire People with Disabilities

Only 19.1% of disabled Americans are employed compared with 65.9% of the general population, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. Qualified job seekers with disabilities may be held back by companies’ fear of expensive accommodations or compliance regulations.If you’re interested in hiring people with disabilities, look no further. We’ve answered FAQs to help you remain complaint. Q: How does the federal government define "disability"? A: The concept of “disability” is defined by context. For employers, a person with a disability is someone who: has a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits one or more "major life activities," has a record of such an impairment, or is regarded as having such an impairment....

Webinar: Winning the Race for Talent - 2/19/20 @2pm ET

Webinar: Winning the Race for Talent - 2/19/20 @2pm ET

Paycor and HORAN Present Winning the Race for Talent Paycor and HORAN are teaming up to share research developed from thousands of organizations that lead to key pillars and a maturity model to help HR Professionals improve practices. Through the HR Center of Excellence, HR professionals can extend their reach and unlock their potential via professional advice, inspiration and action items that will help them make a difference in their organizations. This webinar will focus on the recruiting pillar and how HR leaders can effectively manage people to positively impact their organizations’ bottom line.Speaker: John Allen John is the Channel Partnership Director for Paycor where he focuses on delivering “Paycor value” to our Agency...

Webinar: March 2020 Web Summit - Soldier to Civilian: An Untapped Resource - 3/4/20 @3pm ET

Webinar: March 2020 Web Summit - Soldier to Civilian: An Untapped Resource - 3/4/20 @3pm ET

Do you know all the skills veterans can bring to the workforce? How about teamwork, performing under pressure and leadership skills just to name a few. In this session we’ll discuss the many reasons why veterans make great candidates for a number of job positions. Speaker: Rob ArndtRob Arndt is the Senior Vice President of Business Development with RecruitMilitary & Bradley-Morris Inc., the Nation’s largest and most effective connection point between smart organizations and the highly sought-after military experienced talent pool.Rob is a 14-year Veteran of the United States Marine Corps, who had served in military campaigns in Kuwait and Iraq before reporting to a duty assignment in Marine Corps Recruitment & Retention that...