Can a Disengaged Employee Be Saved?
Can a Disengaged Employee Be Saved?

Can a Disengaged Employee Be Saved?

The ideal employee experience begins with hopeful, positive expectations on both ends; however, we all know things don't always work out for the best. Employees wander off the path and get disengaged for many reasons.

Workers are more engaged in their first six months on a job than they are at any other stage of their employment with a company. At the six-month mark, after the honeymoon is over, about half (52%) of employees remain engaged. Forty percent are not engaged at all, and approximately one in 10 (8%) is actively disengaged, according to Gallup.

Unengaged Workers are a Big Problem

For the past several years, Gallup surveys have revealed that, overall, only about a third of the workforce is actively engaged - and disengaged employees cost the country somewhere between $483 and $605 billion every year - so clearly, this is a serious problem. All too often, this lack of engagement happens on teams where managers become too complacent and don't realize their employees have become less committed to their jobs and the company as a whole.

woman daydreaming at work

How to Identify when an Employee is Disengaged

Unfortunately, your employees typically don't tell you point-blank that they're disengaged; they might not even be aware of it themselves. So, first things first: How do you identify disengaged employees?

Here are 10 signs your employees are disengaged:

  1. Provide frequent excuses for why their work is late or their production isn't up-to-par.
  2. Take single PTO days multiple weeks in a row (a classic indicator that there's a job search underway)
  3. Stop being team players.
  4. Recently start updating their LinkedIn profiles.
  5. Lie about the status of their work.
  6. Have difficulty with their manager or have had multiple managers in a short period of time.
  7. Lack enthusiasm for their jobs.
  8. Have had a close friend at work leave the company.
  9. Lack initiative.
  10. Are comfortable with status quo and exhibit no desire to grow.

woman terminated from job

Is the Team Member Worth Saving?

Once you've identified your employees who are less-than-connected, you have to ask yourself, "Do I want to keep this employee?" Yes, this might sound like a harsh question, but remember, keeping an employee on your payroll who might never change isn't good for anyone. At the same time, you don't want to make a knee-jerk decision and terminate the employee right off the bat. After all, engagement is a spectrum and at any given time, nearly 70% of the American workforce is not exactly engaged with their work. So, letting someone go isn't always going to solve the problem. Think about where your employees land on a disengagement scale of "At Risk," "Complacent," and "Toxic." If they are already toxic, chances are they can't be saved, but you can likely work with the other two types.

The best way to assess whether an employee is worth spending time and money trying to re-engage is to ask questions:

  • Does the employee have the skillsets needed to perform well in this position and make a positive impact on the organization? If not, it may be best to part ways.

  • Does the employee recognize that their behavior is problematic? Sometimes they don't. Tell the employee that you're concerned about the obvious lack of engagement and ask them what's going on. Then listen. Once you've determined the root cause(s) of the disengagement, ask the employee,

  • "If [the reason for disengagement] was fixed right now, how would your performance change?" If the answer is immediate and hopeful, the employee can likely be turned around. If the answer is, "I don't know," or "I don't think it would," that employee will continue to be a detriment to the team and you should consider measures to either re-assign or terminate.

  • Is the employee motivated to take action? If the employee responds positively to the above question, you should outline the benefits of improving the behavior as well as the consequences of not making improvements. This can be informal documentation or official in the form of a personal development plan.

woman yawning bored at work

How to Save Your Best People

Assuming you come to the decision that an employee is, in fact worth saving, here are some things you can do to get them re-engaged:

  • Find out what motivates them. Your employees want to know that you're invested in their careers. Discovering what drives positive behavior and reinforcing that will help with engagement. Everyone wants to be appreciated.

  • Create a personal development plan (PDP). People often give up/become disengaged when they don't think there is opportunity. A PDP can help get them working toward a goal. Making sure their career path is clear can help them get motivated for what's next.

  • Recognize them. Recognition reinforces the positive behaviors you want your checked-out employees to exhibit. Depending on whether they're introverted or extroverted, the recognition can be a simple "thank you" email or it can be public thanks in front of the entire team.

  • Examine changes you can make. Think about what you can do differently as a manager to help your employees succeed. Nobody's perfect. Maybe you need to have more of an open-door policy or you should rein in the micromanaging.

When previously engaged employees are checked out, they have a negative impact on the whole team. Motivation, collaboration, and productivity all take a hit. Following these tips to turn around the disengagement can help your team member return to delivering great work and results and get the entire team back on track.

About Paycor

Paycor creates HR software for leaders who want to make a difference. Our Human Capital Management (HCM) platform modernizes every aspect of people management, from the way you recruit, onboard and develop people, to the way you pay and retain them. But what really sets us apart is our focus on business leaders. For 30 years, we’ve been listening to and partnering with leaders, so we know what they need: HR technology that saves time, powerful analytics that provide actionable insights and dedicated support from HR experts. That’s why more than 30,000 medium & small businesses trust Paycor to help them solve problems and achieve their goals.

For more inspiration and action plans to create a meaningful experience for your employees, visit our dedicated resource hub.

More to Discover

Leave of Absence Policy and Acceptance Letter Template

Leave of Absence Policy and Acceptance Letter Template

Every business needs a leave of absence policy that clearly lays out how employees can apply for time away from work, and what the terms of this leave will be. There are many reasons an employee may require a leave of absence from work and while employers usually have the right to reject a request, it’s almost always the right call to allow employees to take leave.The distress and uncertainty caused by COVID-19 has only made it more important that businesses take an understanding approach to employee welfare, even if they are not eligible for FMLA leave. Whatever the reason an employee needs some time away from work, it’s important that, when accepting such a request, employers lay out exactly what it means for an employee’s status in...

COVID & the Future of Work: Insights from Paycor’s C-Suite

COVID & the Future of Work: Insights from Paycor’s C-Suite

The long-term future is impossible to predict, but what might all this mean, and how will work change, over the next year?In Paycor’s latest report, our Chief Executives and Group Leaders consider how SMBs will recruit, manage their workforce, optimize benefits and foster employee experience in the new normal of 2020.Download our guide to learn more.

Webinar: Remote Work 2020: Keeping Culture Strong Post COVID-19

Webinar: Remote Work 2020: Keeping Culture Strong Post COVID-19

Workplaces across the country will never be the same post COVID-19. Some employees will work from home permanently. Others may slowly return to the office but feel the impacts of social distancing and newly configured spaces. Amidst all the change and uncertainty, culture has never been more important. In this session, we will offer tips to help your culture thrive in this new normal.Speaker: Melanie Booher Melanie Booher is a proactive people connector, genuine leader, change agent, culture-champion and entrepreneurial business coach. Her passion lies in generating meaningful change in the areas of HR, People Operations, Talent Management, Leadership Development, Business Strategy and Culture-Shaping.

Webinar: Post COVID-19: Reimagining the Future of Work

Webinar: Post COVID-19: Reimagining the Future of Work

Join us for a special roundtable discussion on what the future holds for HR leaders post COVID-19 featuring HR experts Jennifer McClure, Jon Thurmond, Wendy Dailey and Joey Price. They will discuss a variety of topics including how to navigate this new normal, new challenges facing HR leaders, personal experiences on motivating employees and keeping engagement strong and much more.