I-9 Compliance: Don't Let Common Errors Sink Future Growth
I-9 Compliance: Don't Let Common Errors Sink Future Growth

I-9 Compliance: Don't Let Common Errors Sink Future Growth

Cutting corners when it came to verifying the eligibility of employees for small and mid-size businesses, via Form I-9, was at one time quite frequent. The Immigration Reform and Control Act, first passed in 1986, subsequently added numerous amendments and revisions that made compliance a difficult task for employers. Lax oversight by both business and law enforcement bore out bad habits by all.

For employers, those days are now gone. U.S. Immigrations and Customs Enforcement (ICE) are making sure companies large and small are Form I-9 compliant. Heavy fines and penalties that threaten the growth, and sometimes existence, of businesses are commonplace for those not fully committed to checking work eligibility requirements. Effective worksite enforcement, including civil and criminal action, await those who fail to comply.

And Form I-9 audits don’t merely focus on the employees hired, but also the paperwork itself. So even if your workers are authorized and verified, errors in Form I-9 completion and filing can result in fines if it’s determined inaccuracies or procedural inconsistencies occurred knowingly. This can place a heavy burden on employers to correctly work within legal parameters, but work within those parameters they must. The alternative can be a crushing blow.

  • A Masonry company in Georgia was audited by ICE in 2010 and two counts were brought against the company. Count 1 involved improper filing of Form I-9 section 1 by 277 different employees, and count 2 alleged the company failed to properly prepare or complete forms for 87 employees. The business was using partially prepopulated forms with a rubber stamping process prior to completion. Fines ranging from $110 to $1000 per employee meant that a grand total of $332,000 was initially levied against the business. All from paperwork violations.

  • A California business providing electronics to aerospace, military and medical markets was audited for non-compliant hiring practices. It was found that paperwork deficiencies in Form I-9 led to 62 employee violations for a total of $63,767 in fines. The business freely admitted to the mistakes made and instead challenged the judgement on the grounds of reasonability compared to the perceived violation. It didn’t matter. The presiding judge ruled that admission was enough to collect the fine. Once again, due to paperwork infractions.

Maintaining eligibility guidelines, including strict I-9 compliance, is essential for employers to prevent crippling liability. The best way to establish these guidelines is with a knowledgeable partner. Paycor specializes in helping businesses of all sizes with Onboarding and HR solutions, offering trusted guidance to a sometimes overwhelming process. Contact us to see how we can best serve you.


Subscribe to Our Resource Center Digest

Enter your email below to receive a weekly recap of the latest articles from Paycor's Resource Center.

Check your inbox for an email confirming your subscription. Enjoy!

More to Discover

Webinar: National Payroll Week Webinar Series: COVID's Impact on Multi State Taxation

Webinar: National Payroll Week Webinar Series: COVID's Impact on Multi State Taxation

During National Payroll Week, Paycor hosted three webinars to help business leaders prepare for compliance changes and new trends in 2021.The COVID pandemic has forced many employees to shift from the office to remote work environments. As many organizations juggle the new challenges, business leaders must also evaluate their expanded footprint and how taxes are impacted. In this webinar, Paycor’s resident tax expert, James Schwantes will highlight tax considerations employers need to know.Speaker: Jim Schwantes

Webinar: National Payroll Week Webinar Series: How to Prevent a Payroll Lawsuit

Webinar: National Payroll Week Webinar Series: How to Prevent a Payroll Lawsuit

During National Payroll Week, Paycor hosted three webinars to help business leaders prepare for compliance changes and new trends in 2021. In this webinar, we'll breakdown everything HR leaders need to know to avoid costly errors and payroll lawsuits.Speaker: Becky Stauffer Becky started her own consulting company Work4Accord, LLC where she serves National and Regional clients. Becky is a “Professional Encourager of Others”. She is active in communities that support professional growth including the SHRM, Society for Human Resource Management and the NSA, National Speakers Association. Becky holds a SPHR, Senior Professional in Human Resources, SHRM-SCP Senior Certified Professional and a Master’s in Public Administration from the...

Webinar: Getting it All Done: 6 Compliance Issues your HR Department Must Embrace - 10/27 @2pm ET

Webinar: Getting it All Done: 6 Compliance Issues your HR Department Must Embrace - 10/27 @2pm ET

For HR departments to avoid costly errors and fines, there are 6 areas of compliance they need to consistently follow. During this webinar, we’ll breakdown each area and provide actionable steps to take to gain visibility as a strategic HR leader at your organization. Don’t miss this session! Register now. Speaker: Lori Kleiman Lori Kleiman is a business expert with more than 25 years of experience advising companies on HR issues. Her background as a human resources professional and consultant gives her unique insight on how HR professionals and executives can work together effectively to achieve business goals. Her programs are designed to provide critical HR updates and best practices to small businesses. In addition, she is has served...

Webinar: National Payroll Week Webinar Series: Payroll Compliance Updates & What's Ahead in 2021

Webinar: National Payroll Week Webinar Series: Payroll Compliance Updates & What's Ahead in 2021

From new salary thresholds and social security wage increases to COVID tax relief, businesses leaders have faced quite a few payroll and tax changes in 2020. As we prepare to turn the page to a new year, what new updates are on the horizon? Join Paycor’s resident payroll expert, Arlene Baker to learn about the latest updates and what you should watch out for in 2021.Speaker: Arlene Baker Arlene Baker is a Sr Compliance Analyst with over 40 years of payroll and tax experience. Arlene is a member of the National Payroll Reporting Consortium focusing on IRS compliance. Arlene has been a member of the national and local APA for 25 years and is an active member of the American Payroll Association Hotline and SPLTF Hospitality Industry...