I-9 Compliance: Don't Let Common Errors Sink Future Growth
I-9 Compliance: Don't Let Common Errors Sink Future Growth

I-9 Compliance: Don't Let Common Errors Sink Future Growth

Cutting corners when it came to verifying the eligibility of employees for small and mid-size businesses, via Form I-9, was at one time quite frequent. The Immigration Reform and Control Act, first passed in 1986, subsequently added numerous amendments and revisions that made compliance a difficult task for employers. Lax oversight by both business and law enforcement bore out bad habits by all.

For employers, those days are now gone. U.S. Immigrations and Customs Enforcement (ICE) are making sure companies large and small are Form I-9 compliant. Heavy fines and penalties that threaten the growth, and sometimes existence, of businesses are commonplace for those not fully committed to checking work eligibility requirements. Effective worksite enforcement, including civil and criminal action, await those who fail to comply.

And Form I-9 audits don’t merely focus on the employees hired, but also the paperwork itself. So even if your workers are authorized and verified, errors in Form I-9 completion and filing can result in fines if it’s determined inaccuracies or procedural inconsistencies occurred knowingly. This can place a heavy burden on employers to correctly work within legal parameters, but work within those parameters they must. The alternative can be a crushing blow.

  • A Masonry company in Georgia was audited by ICE in 2010 and two counts were brought against the company. Count 1 involved improper filing of Form I-9 section 1 by 277 different employees, and count 2 alleged the company failed to properly prepare or complete forms for 87 employees. The business was using partially prepopulated forms with a rubber stamping process prior to completion. Fines ranging from $110 to $1000 per employee meant that a grand total of $332,000 was initially levied against the business. All from paperwork violations.

  • A California business providing electronics to aerospace, military and medical markets was audited for non-compliant hiring practices. It was found that paperwork deficiencies in Form I-9 led to 62 employee violations for a total of $63,767 in fines. The business freely admitted to the mistakes made and instead challenged the judgement on the grounds of reasonability compared to the perceived violation. It didn’t matter. The presiding judge ruled that admission was enough to collect the fine. Once again, due to paperwork infractions.

Maintaining eligibility guidelines, including strict I-9 compliance, is essential for employers to prevent crippling liability. The best way to establish these guidelines is with a knowledgeable partner. Paycor specializes in helping businesses of all sizes with Onboarding and HR solutions, offering trusted guidance to a sometimes overwhelming process. Contact us to see how we can best serve you.


Subscribe to Our Resource Center Digest

Enter your email below to receive a weekly recap of the latest articles from Paycor's Resource Center.

Check your inbox for an email confirming your subscription. Enjoy!

More to Discover

SaaS Payroll: 6 Tips to Find the Perfect Solution

SaaS Payroll: 6 Tips to Find the Perfect Solution

Software as a Service (SaaS) is the term used for software that’s delivered and used totally online or in the cloud. As more businesses turn to online solutions to manage their workflows, do accounting, etc., it should be no surprise to see that payroll processing is no exception. From tax-filing and employee self-service to data security and compliance management, SaaS payroll automates routine tasks and ensures accuracy, so business leaders can focus on what really matters, improving the bottom line. If you’re in the market for an online payroll system, you’ll need a sharp eye to find the perfect match for your organization. Keep in mind, not all payroll software is created equal. Whether you want to go with a bare-bones solution or...

10 Must Haves for HR SaaS

10 Must Haves for HR SaaS

Software as a Service (SaaS) is the term used for software that’s delivered and used entirely online or in the cloud, meaning that no software is actually installed on employees’ hard drives. More and more businesses are turning to cloud-based solutions to manage their workflows, run accounting and control their supply chains, often as part of a larger enterprise resources planning (ERP) solution. Probably not surprisingly to most, the HR function is no exception. A SaaS human resources solution can enable small and midsize business owners to control every aspect of their employee management tasks online. And in doing so, HR departments can eliminate mundane and error-prone manual tasks such as wrangling multiple spreadsheets and...

Paid Sick Leave Laws By State

Paid Sick Leave Laws By State

Everyone, at one time or another, has worked with that person who comes to work with a bad cold (We’re hopeful it wasn’t you). Not only is it annoying, it also jeopardizes the health of other employees. But have you ever stopped to think that maybe that co-worker came to work because they didn’t have enough paid sick time available and wouldn’t get paid for a missed day or two? Here’s a high-level overview of states’ paid sick leave laws for private sector employers. Keep in mind this list is not inclusive of every state’s laws; there are many more nuances to understand and comply with. Alabama Paid Sick Leave Laws No state sick leave laws. Alaska Paid Sick Leave Laws No state sick leave laws. Arizona Paid Sick Leave Laws Covered...

Compliance with State and Municipality Sick Leaves

Compliance with State and Municipality Sick Leaves

In the past, granting paid sick leave was at the employer’s discretion in the private sector. While employees are covered for long-term leave under the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA), there’s no federal paid sick leave act that requires private employers to pay for short-term sick leave. But now we’re seeing a growing movement of laws being created at the state and municipality levels that are designed to protect employees who might be forced to choose between going to work sick and infecting their co-workers, or calling in sick and potentially losing pay and, in the worst-case scenario, even their jobs. Paid sick leave gives an employee financial peace of mind when they find that they can’t work because either they’re sick or...