Is Unlimited PTO a Good Idea?
Is Unlimited PTO a Good Idea?

Is Unlimited PTO a Good Idea?

If you’re debating whether or not to offer unlimited paid time off to your workforce, there are a few pros and cons to keep in mind.

For starters, it is becoming more prevalent. The number of jobs on Indeed that advertise unlimited PTO increased 178% between 2015 and 2019. But still, only 1%-2% of companies in the U.S. offer unlimited vacation and most of those companies are in the tech industry (ex. Hubspot, Netflix, Roku), according to Society for Human Resource Management.

Why Do Companies Offer Unlimited PTO?

Offering unlimited vacation is an innovative tactic for recruiting talent. Afterall, who hasn’t daydreamed of taking off work whenever the mood suits? In fact, the 2019 MetLife Employee Benefit Trends Survey revealed that 72% of employees are interested in unlimited paid time off. The desire for unlimited PTO ranked highest of the emerging benefits, beating phased retirement programs, paid sabbaticals and wellness programs that reward healthy behavior.

Today, nearly 75% of workers have access to paid vacations. The average amount is 14 days after one year of service and 24 days at 20 years according to the Department of Labor.

But unlimited paid time off isn’t a perk that’s offered everywhere, and it can help attract the right employees for the job. New hires appreciate not having to wait to accrue PTO, which can make employees more engaged right off the bat.

It also frees up some time for HR by eliminating the tedious task of formally tracking absences. And, with an unlimited PTO policy, employers no longer have to pay for unused vacation days if employees quit or get fired.

The novelty of offering unlimited vacation can be a game changer. It makes your organization stand out to prospective hires, it can improve the time-to-fill job openings, boost employee morale, rejuvenate productivity, reduce employee burnout and increase the trust level between employee and employer.

How to Start an Unlimited Vacation Policy

It’s smart to have a plan when implementing an unlimited PTO policy. First, be prepared to pay employees for any unused PTO before you make the switch. This will help diminish anyone with accrued vacation time from feeling slighted.

employees on pto

Second, it’s critical that employers communicate clear expectations from the beginning regarding how it’s going to work, scheduling procedures, etc. Your workforce needs to understand that just because there’s unlimited PTO doesn’t mean everyone can take off for the entire summer.

The company culture also needs to be one where company leaders spend time encouraging employees to use vacation days. If upper management doesn’t lead by example, sometimes employees feel guilty for taking vacation and may even compete to prove who is most “loyal” to the company by NOT taking any amount of time off.

Human resources is the bridge between company policy and execution and should always be looking for ways to make the company culture employee focused. Unlimited PTO is a great start, but also consider other employee-centric policies such as flexibility in scheduling, remote work, programs that reward healthy behavior (smoking cessation, weight loss, pregnancy 101), phased retirement programs.

For more insights on how big a difference benefits make, check out our latest findings in The HR Playbook: Reduce Turnover with Employee Benefits. And for more information on how Paycor’s technology can help optimize your HR process, visit our Solution Finder.


hr tool solution finder

More to Discover

Webinar: Benefit Advisor: A Simple Solution for the Complex World of Benefits

Webinar: Benefit Advisor: A Simple Solution for the Complex World of Benefits

SHRM's Employee Benefit Reports found that when companies use benefits strategically, they see improved recruiting effectiveness and higher employee retention. In fact, when we analyzed our own data from 30,000 clients, we found the right mix of benefits can improve turnover by 138%. To help your clients achieve these results with benefits, we've partnered with bSwift to simplify your client's Open Enrollment Experience with the Open Enrollment Wizard.Speakers: Kelly Silverman and Mike MasiniKelly Silverman is Paycor's resident benefits and HR marketing leader. An HCM industry veteran with a strong product and marketing background, Kelly’s responsibilities include driving the go-to-market strategy for benefits and analytics to Paycor’s...

The HR Playbook: Reduce Turnover with Employee Benefits

The HR Playbook: Reduce Turnover with Employee Benefits

You know benefits are important to employees, but you might be surprised how big of an impact they actually have on employee turnover. After analyzing data from more than 30,000 medium and small businesses nationwide, Paycor discovered that as organizations add benefit plans, there is a significant decrease in turnover.In fact, organizations that offered the right mix of benefits saw turnover decrease 138%.The key is finding that right mix of benefits. Different generations want different things, and designing a benefits plan that fits a multigenerational workforce isn’t easy, but worth it in the long run in order to retain and attract talent.And that’s just the beginning. There are several factors to consider when designing competitive...

Product Case Study: Benefits Advisor and HR

Product Case Study: Benefits Advisor and HR

Paycor’s HR and Benefits Advisor Allows the Kansas City Zoo to Streamline Open Enrollment. “My favorite thing about Benefits Advisor is the employee self-service—giving them the responsibility. It’s really easy to see what people are enrolled in at a glance and it has a clean look to it, which I like.” - Janna Stewart, HR manager, Kansas City Zoo CHALLENGE For years, the Kansas City Zoo used a manual paper- based method to onboard new employees, conduct performance reviews and during open enrollment. It was time consuming and required physical space to store all employee data and files. HR PAIN POINT Manual open enrollment & performance reviews Required multiple data entry points SOLUTION Streamline open enrollment Employee...

Webinar: Benefit Advisor Transition and Demo Journey

Webinar: Benefit Advisor Transition and Demo Journey

Deep dive into the new Benefit Advisor platform with Paycor’s lead Benefits Transition Specialists. You will walk away with an understanding of the product, features and how they will improve the lives of the administrator, employee and your organization. Additionally, our specialists will provide an overview of the transition journey to help ensure success.