I-9 Compliance: How to Avoid Costly Mistakes
I-9 Compliance: How to Avoid Costly Mistakes

I-9 Compliance: How to Avoid Costly Mistakes

To say that I-9 compliance is complex is an understatement. The proper steps organizations must follow to ensure accurate completion and retention can be daunting. In this article, Paycor offers best practices and details the steps organizations need to take to prevent penalties and fines using our Onboarding solution.

Form I-9 – What is it?

Form I-9 is used to verify the identity and employment authorization of individuals hired for employment in the United States. All U.S. employers must ensure proper completion of an I-9 for each individual that they hire.

Proper Filing For a two-page form, the I-9 can be one of the most intimidating documents for employers because of the strict guidelines that must be followed to complete it correctly. The law requires that the employer make the forms available upon request by authorized government offices after being provided 3 days’ notice prior to an inspection.

Proper Retention Form I-9 should be retained for as long as the employee is working for you, and for 3 years after the date of hire, or 1 year after termination, whichever date is later.

To calculate how long to keep an employee’s Form I-9, enter the following:

• Employee’s Start Date + three years = date A • Employee’s Termination Date + one year = date B • Store their form I-9 until the later of the two dates

Who Completes Form I-9?

Section 1 – Employee Section In this section, the employee enters their full, legal name, including any other names used such as maiden names, followed by their home address and date of birth. One common mistake that Monica often encounters is employees who accidentally enter their date of birth for today’s date on the signature line. Pay close attention to this detail as your new hires complete their information.

Section 2, Part 1 - Employer Section This section must be completed by the employer or an employer representative (someone acting on the employer’s behalf). If an employer representative does complete the form, the employer is still liable for any violations in connection with the form or verification process. Possibly the most important part of Form I-9 is that this section must be completed within 3 business days of the employee’s first day of employment.

It’s also important to note is that the same person who reviews and validates employee IDs must fully complete the employer’s section. For instance, it is not permissible for a manager to review a new hire’s IDs while HR completes the employer’s section.

Section 2, Part II – Certification The dates in this section are very important, so pay close attention to them. First is: “The employee’s first day of employment” which is the date of hire, or the exact date that an employee began employment for wages. This date must match the payroll and timekeeping records. The second date is simply the date that you examined the IDs your employee presented and completed the employer’s section. This date must be within 3 business days of the date employment.

When is Form I-9 Not Required? Volunteers, unpaid interns and independent contractors do not need to complete the form.

I-9 Employer Penalties Failure to properly complete, retain and/or make an I-9 available for inspection may result in a civil penalty in an amount between $216 and $2,216 for each violation.

Hot off the Press: Form I-9 Updates Released

On Tuesday, November 14, the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) published a revised version of the Form I-9.

The USCIS has revised Form I-9 in order to make employers’ lives easier. In fact, “changes are designed to reduce errors and enhance form completion using a computer”. While this may make it easier to complete a singular Form I-9, this process represents another compliance change for employers.

What: A revised Form I-9 with slightly adjusted fields and drop downs. Users can now add multiple preparers and translators, and may also utilize a new area specifically for additional employee information. Section 1 of the Form I-9 also adjusted some language, such as requiring “Other Last Names Used” vs “Other Names Used”. • When: While the USCIS recommends immediately utilizing the revised form, organizations are not required to use the revised Form I-9 until January 22, 2017. • Who: All employers.

What Should You Do?

Maintaining eligibility guidelines, including strict I-9 compliance, is essential for employers to prevent crippling liability. The best way to avoid any errors is to electronically require your employees to complete the Form I-9 before their first day at work. Paycor’s Onboarding solution will not only include an updated Form I-9, but will also allow you to have employees electronically complete the document. The Form I-9 will then be electronically stored to their record, ensuring simple and easy maintenance for you.

To make sure you are following the proper procedures when hiring a new employee, download Paycor's Form I-9 Guide and Checklist.

This content is for educational purposes only and is not intended to serve as legal advice.


subscribe to Paycor's Resource Center

Subscribe to Our Resource Center Digest

Enter your email below to receive a weekly recap of the latest articles from Paycor's Resource Center.

Check your inbox for an email confirming your subscription. Enjoy!

More to Discover

Case Study: Rochester University

Case Study: Rochester University

Michigan based Rochester University relied on their own payroll processing for nearly 60 years. But when their payroll administrator decided to retire, they turned to Paycor to help them save time and resources. “In the three years we’ve been a Paycor customer, I’ve never had a problem reaching my dedicated support team. I always get a call back and most of the time it’s on the same day. If I have an emergency, I know I can trust Paycor.” – Ginny May, Director of HR With Paycor, Rochester University has significantly transformed how they manage HR and process payroll with Paycor Time, Paycor’s Mobile App and ACA filing. By eliminating manual work, their staff has more time to focus on strategic initiatives like finding the right faculty...

4 Common Payroll Mistakes and How to Fix Them

4 Common Payroll Mistakes and How to Fix Them

Overtime Pay, Pay Equity, Workers’ Comp, Payroll Taxes Topics Covered Missclassifying Employees Pay Equity Workers' Comp Payroll Taxes Dump Your Payroll Provider Payroll Compliance: More Complex Than You Think From FLSA, EPA, Workers Comp and more, there are lots of federal laws to keep track of, and state and local taxes only add complexity. That’s why HR and business leaders need to have processes in place to consistently apply pay policies, accurately calculate overtime and streamline leave policies. If you don’t and your company is audited or sued, you won’t have the proper controls in place to quickly provide accurate records and audit trails. Here are four common Payroll mistakes you might be making: Misclassifying Freelancers and...

Webinar: How Paycor Can Take Blackbaud's Payroll 7 Clients To The Next Level - 12/11/2019 @2pm ET

Webinar: How Paycor Can Take Blackbaud's Payroll 7 Clients To The Next Level - 12/11/2019 @2pm ET

Blackbaud’s Payroll clients have been asking for a more robust payroll offering and we’re excited to announce a new partnership between Blackbaud and Paycor.An industry-leading HR and payroll provider with nearly 30 years of experience serving small to medium-sized businesses, Paycor will not only deliver more robust payroll functionality, but also a suite of products and services to help Blackbaud clients better serve their mission.Join us on December 11th as Paycor Senior Vice President, Rick Chouteau, and Blackbaud Partner Development Leader, Craig Suppin, showcase why Paycor can be chosen to replace the Payroll 7 module, helping your organization improve operational efficiencies while reducing risk.In this webinar, we’ll share: • A...

DOL Final Overtime Rules: Quickstart Guide for Employers

DOL Final Overtime Rules: Quickstart Guide for Employers

On September 24, 2019, the Department of Labor issued its final overtime rule to increase the minimum salary threshold for executive, administrative and professional exemptions from $455 per week ($23,660 annually) to $684 per week ($35,568 annually). The new rule goes into effect January 1, 2020.As your organization considers how to prepare and comply, we’ve created this guide which outlines the new ruling, provides tips to manage impacted employees and offers a checklist of key details to follow to mitigate risk. Click below to instantly download the guide.