Should we participate in the Best Place to Work contest?
best-place-to-work-contest

Should we participate in the Best Place to Work contest?

By Jason Lauritsen

As a growing company, differentiating yourself as an employer of choice is critical to attracting talent. Being named to a “Best Place to Work” list is a powerful way to show your commitment to creating a great workplace for employees.

There are Best Places to Work contests in most cities, often several different competing programs. There are state and national contests as well. Your industry might even have its own contests (i.e., healthcare). If you are motivated to pursue recognition of this type, you have plenty of options.

But should you?

As someone who ran these programs for a few years, I am commonly asked by both business leaders and HR professionals if they should enter one. My answer: it depends.

In most cases, entering an employer of choice contest requires participation from your employees, usually in the form of an employee survey. This decision should be made thoughtfully because participation in this program will have side effects that can be either positive or negative, depending on your approach.

Below are some questions to help you decide if participating in a Best Place to Work contest is a good idea for your organization.

1. Is your organization actively investing in trying to be an amazing workplace for your employees?

Most of these programs use employee satisfaction and engagement as the primary measurement of a best place to work. If your leadership team isn’t committed to employee engagement and creating a great workplace for employees, you might want to hold off on a contest for now because it could backfire.

When you participate in a contest like this and send the survey to employees, it sends a message that you (HR and/or leadership) think you are worthy of recognition. If your employees haven’t seen or heard of any real internal efforts to improve their work experience, this can feel disconnected and dishonest – fueling disengagement.

On the other hand, if your organization regularly talks about and acts to improve employee engagement, then employees will probably feel like taking a best place to work survey makes sense and further reinforces their experience.

2. Are you prepared not to make the list?

These contests are competitive, particularly for small and medium-sized companies. In some cases, only a fraction of those who enter are recognized. So, if you are considering participating, expect that you may not make the list the first time.

Before you decide to participate, you need to play out how you will respond and communicate to employees if you fail to make the list. By sending out the survey as part of the process, you’ve communicated to your employees that the organization is committed to becoming a best place to work. If your executives aren’t able or willing to communicate uncomfortable messages, it might be best to hold off on participating.

Not making the list can be a powerful opportunity to reinforce your commitment to the employee experience, but you must have a plan for what comes next. Which brings me to the following question.

3. Are you prepared to take feedback from the process and do something with it?

Employer of choice contests are a great opportunity to compare your culture and work experience to your industry peers. Generally, you can gain some great insights and feedback to benchmark your internal practices against other organizations with whom you compete for talent.

But you must be prepared to do something with this information. Any time you survey employees, the two most important things you must do are communicate what you heard through the survey and then take some visible action informed by the results. This process is no different. To participate without following up by sharing results and an action plan can harm your relationship with employees.

No one likes to be asked for their opinion only to have it disregarded or ignored. If you choose to participate, take full advantage of the feedback by ensuring you have a plan in place to close the loop and demonstrate follow-up action.

Making the call

If your organization is fully committed to creating a great place to work and you are actively investing time and energy in doing so, participating in a Best Place to Work contest can be a great opportunity and a useful tool. Just remember that what’s most important in the process isn’t making the list but using the process to support your efforts and reinforce your commitment to creating a great workplace.

Good luck!


About the Author

Jason Lauritsen is a keynote speaker and employee engagement expert who has dedicated his career to helping leaders and employees create a more fulfilling work experience. For nearly a decade, he spent his days as a corporate Human Resources executive where he developed a reputation for driving business results through talent. Most recently, he led the research team for Quantum Workplace’s Best Places to Work program where he has studied the employee experience at thousands of companies to understand what the best workplaces in the world do differently than the rest.

More to Discover

COVID & the Future of Work: Insights from Paycor’s C-Suite

COVID & the Future of Work: Insights from Paycor’s C-Suite

The long-term future is impossible to predict, but what might all this mean, and how will work change, over the next year?In Paycor’s latest report, our Chief Executives and Group Leaders consider how SMBs will recruit, manage their workforce, optimize benefits and foster employee experience in the new normal of 2020.Download our guide to learn more.

Webinar: Remote Work 2020: Keeping Culture Strong Post COVID-19

Webinar: Remote Work 2020: Keeping Culture Strong Post COVID-19

Workplaces across the country will never be the same post COVID-19. Some employees will work from home permanently. Others may slowly return to the office but feel the impacts of social distancing and newly configured spaces. Amidst all the change and uncertainty, culture has never been more important. In this session, we will offer tips to help your culture thrive in this new normal.Speaker: Melanie Booher Melanie Booher is a proactive people connector, genuine leader, change agent, culture-champion and entrepreneurial business coach. Her passion lies in generating meaningful change in the areas of HR, People Operations, Talent Management, Leadership Development, Business Strategy and Culture-Shaping.

Webinar: 5 Ways to Cheer Up Your Employees

Webinar: 5 Ways to Cheer Up Your Employees

During this difficult time of uncertainty many employees feel disconnected from their coworkers and uncertain about their futures. As a leader there are a few things you can do to engage your employees who are working from home. Join us as we cover 5 ways to cheer up your employees. Speaker: Colin Ethier As manager, content marketing, Colin is responsible for creating innovative content and webinar strategies that drive demand and showcase Paycor’s differentiating expertise in the HCM market. Prior to his role in content marketing, Colin supported internal communications at Paycor.

Is Your Organization Ready for Employee Self-Service?

Is Your Organization Ready for Employee Self-Service?

HR Isn't Being Replaced Is Self-Service Right for You Benefits of Self-Service Must-Have Features What is Employee Self-Service? At its core, employee self-service (ESS) gives workers access to their personal records and information. Through employee self-service portals (housed in HRIS systems), employees can change their contact and banking information, access their payroll, schedules, benefits enrollment and more, without HR being involved. Why Some HR Leaders are Skeptical of Automating HR Processes To many HR leaders, the empowerment of ESS means the golden age of HR has arrived. Instead of spending hours on administrative tasks, HR leaders can now focus on strategic initiatives like recruiting, retention and employee development....