Managing a Multigenerational Workforce
workforce with multiple generations

Managing a Multigenerational Workforce

Employees across five different generations are making valuable contributions in today’s business world, but each generation comes to work with a different set of preferences for learning and coaching. Because receiving feedback and seeing a path to career growth are key factors in determining employee satisfaction, it’s imperative that HR professionals know how to navigate the needs of their employees regardless of their age.

The five multigenerational employee bands include:

Generation Name  Born 
Traditionalists  Before 1946 
Baby Boomers  Between 1946 and 1964 
Generation X  Between 1965 and 1976 
Generation Y, or Millennials  Between 1977 and 1997 
Generation Z  After 1997 


Following are some of the differences among the generations and how they affect management dynamics.

Employee feedback and coaching

As times have changed, so has the way employees wish to have their performance reviewed and receive coaching. For Traditionalists, no news is seen as good news. They tend not to expect feedback so long as things are going well.

Baby Boomers, on the other hand, expect to receive their performance feedback via a formal review conducted once a year, with lots of documentation to back it up. As a result, Baby Boomer managers often tend to withhold feedback until review time because they didn’t receive much from the Traditionalists during the formative years of their careers.

This can turn into a sticky situation as Boomers manage reports from younger generations — Generation X, Millennials, and Generation Z — who desire a much greater level of feedback on their performance.

These groups of workers have some commonalities as they are hungry to know where they stand, and they periodically will seek out their managers to ask with an approach that might be described as, “Sorry to interrupt, but how am I doing?” With Millennials, the bar is far higher. Nine of 10 of these newer members of the workforce expect feedback at least once a day.

According to a study conducted by staffing firm Randstadt, perhaps surprisingly, more than half (51%) of Gen Z employees prefer in-person communication with their managers, rather than communication via email (16%) or instant message (11%).

Because of these generational differences in styles, it’s important to have clear policies and procedures in place on a corporate level so all employees understand what is expected of them and how and when they will be evaluated. Job descriptions and performance review forms and practices should be standardized, and HR leaders must proactively coach managers to help them adapt to their direct reports’ various preferences.

coaching-employee

Career development and learning

The generation gap is also evident in how today’s workforce thinks about professional development and continuing education. The ability to visualize a strong career path into the future is a key indicator of whether an employee will stay with an organization or seek more opportunity elsewhere.

Traditionalists tend not to prioritize formalized training to learn new skills or job roles; they’re more in tune with learning on their own as they go. Thus, they might not be quick to offer such training to direct reports. Traditional thinking is, “I learned the hard way, and so will you.”

The Boomers’ thought process is very different but can also lead to a lack of training for their employees. The Boomer generation was raised to believe in lifetime employment with one organization, so they see training less experienced colleagues as potentially risky — train them too much, and they might leave for what they determine are greener pastures.

This way of thinking is in direct opposition to Gen Xers, who have been shown to stay longer at companies where they’re provided more opportunities to learn.

For Millennials, continuous learning is a way of life. Having grown up during uncertain financial times, they’ve seen how economic downturns can dramatically affect employees. Instead of looking for lifetime employment, they’re looking for lifetime employability. Changing jobs is their expectation, so they’re most satisfied when they can improve their résumés and stay marketable.

Much like Millennials, Gen Z workers appreciate a good work-life balance and have the expectation that their employers will provide them with learning and development opportunities. While Millennials are comfortable with a structured program, Gen Z prefers to create their own pathway.

The table below outlines the differences in the employee generations:

Generation Name  Coaching Style and Feedback  Attitude Toward Career Development and Learning 
Traditionalists  Don't expect feedback unless there are problems  Formal training isn't a priority 
Baby Boomers  Expect full-documented annual review Risky to train employees as they may leave company with the new skills 
Generation X  Desire frequent feedback  Exhibit loyalty to organizations investing in their learning 
Generation Y, or Millennials  Desire frequent feedback  Satisfaction comes when they're continually learning 
Generation Z  Expect daily feedback  Expect learning and often create own learning paths 

Want to learn more?

From retention to employee training to HR policies, Paycor’s technology can help you manage your team’s talent. With solutions ranging from affordable, online resources such as HR Support Center to a robust HR solution, we have the tools you need to keep up with changing trends. Learn more about what we can do for your business.


Subscribe to Our Resource Center Digest

Enter your email below to receive a weekly recap of the latest articles from Paycor's Resource Center.

Check your inbox for an email confirming your subscription. Enjoy!

More to Discover

The Turnover Crisis in Healthcare

The Turnover Crisis in Healthcare

An action plan for finance and HR leaders With an aging population, more chronic illnesses and many nurses nearing retirement, the demand for their skilled replacements is outpacing the supply at an alarming rate. In fact, nearly a quarter of healthcare providers reported having nursing vacancies greater than 10% in 2018*. Unemployment rates are at the lowest they’ve been in decades, which makes the search for qualified talent and filling open job positions more difficult than ever. The demand for healthcare isn’t going to diminish, so it’s important to partner with an HCM provider who can help solve your HR challenges with the proper technology and expertise. Nearly 6,000 healthcare providers depend on Paycor for solutions regarding...

Case Study: Humane Society of Boulder Valley

Case Study: Humane Society of Boulder Valley

After years of dealing with cumbersome and unreliable HR software, the Humane Society of Boulder Valley turned to Paycor for a modern, efficient Human Capital Management solution. “Paycor provided improved functionality and additional services for the same price we were paying with our old vendor. [We received] a better value and a more intuitive product.” —Jennifer Schwartz, Director of Human Resources, Humane Society of Boulder Valley Read more about HSBV’s experience using Paycor and how our solutions can meet the needs of other nonprofit organizations.

The Turnover Crisis in Manufacturing

The Turnover Crisis in Manufacturing

An action plan for all HR and finance leaders It’s no secret—manufacturing is losing talent. As Baby Boomers leave the workforce and take valuable skills with them, it’s expected that nearly 3.5 million manufacturing jobs will open up by 2025. Two million of those jobs are expected to go unfilled because of the skills gap*. The longer positions go unfilled, the more the production process is disrupted. Company morale starts to decline, and manufacturers see profits dip as they’re unable to operate at full capacity. Automation and robotics may help fill some of the labor gap, but HR still needs to find humans to problem solve, analyze issues and manage output. If you’re trying to recruit in the manufacturing industry, you’re in a vicious...

EEO Compliance: Are You Prepared to File the Updated EEO-1 Report?

EEO Compliance: Are You Prepared to File the Updated EEO-1 Report?

On April 25, 2019 a federal judge announced a ruling that will require employers to collect 2018 employee pay data and hours worked by race, ethnicity and gender and submit it to the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) by September 30, 2019. On May 1, 2019, the EEOC decided that they will collect 2017 pay data in addition to the 2018 pay data that was previously announced. The EEOC is expected to open the portal for employers to submit 2017 and 2018 pay data beginning on July 15, 2019. Note: Employers are still required to submit component 1 of the EEO-1 form by May 31, 2019. What are the new EEO-1 reporting requirements? The current EEO-1 form requires company employment data to be categorized by race, ethnicity, gender and...